Dustin Kight

Hypocrisy, Alarm, or Something Else, Oh MY!

Filed By Dustin Kight | November 07, 2007 6:00 PM | comments

Filed in: Living, Marriage Equality, Politics
Tags: Barna, Born Again, evangelical Christian, marriage equality, same-sex marriage

For those of you paying close attention in 2004, you probably saw the Barna Group numbers around Born Again Christians and divorce. I was 20 at the time, and paying more attention to research papers. I won't lie.

A little recap: Barna found that the divorce rate among Born Again Christians is nearly the same as that among non-Born Agains. Interestingly, that divorce rate, 35% among married adults, is only slightly less than the rate among avowed Atheists and Agnostics, at 37%. The Barna folks assumed that the rate among Atheists and Agnostics would be higher, since traditional faith barriers don't exist to preclude their divorce.

In general, Barna's assessments of Born Again Christians' experiences with and perspectives on divorce were far more moderate and in line with the mainstream than they expected.

And here's the kicker: 57% of "born-again" Christians age 16-29 criticize their own church for being "anti-homosexual." (This bit was included in a recent article on Time.com, "An Evangelical Rethink On Divorce?"

All of which begs the question: If Born Again Christians are divorcing at essentially the same rate as others -- Atheists, even! -- and their views on divorce are less stringent than one might imagine, and their young are upset about the anti-gay attitudes of their churches, then why all the rhetoric against same-sex marriage?

Now, I know that relaxing attitudes on divorce within their own community doesn't necessarily equate to relaxing attitudes on marriage equality. But come on. Is there no hyprocisy at hand when those who denounce same-sex marriage as an eroding factor on the institution of marriage and the health of "the family" partake in the dissolution of those marriages at the same said rate?

Or does the opposition to marriage equality stem more from a growing sense of alarm among (at least some) Born Agains that the wolves are rubbing elbows (and rubbing off) too much with their flock?

Born Again Christians continue to have a more negative view of divorce than non-Born Agains, even though the difference of opinion is not as large as we might think. A community that continues to hold as a core principle that marriage is sacred and indisolvable (outside of adultery) would be alarmed by having divorce rates "as high" as others. And it's not inconceivable to think that at least some members of the community (opportunistic leaders, for instance) would look for scapegoats (same-sex couples seeking marriage) in order to address the "divorce dilemma" among their own without having to alienate members of their community whose attitudes toward divorce or thawing all the time.

It's not unlike fighting a Cold War, in which domestic problems are addressed or avoided by pointing to an outside issue or force.

Or is there something else going on here that primarily explains the Born Again...discrepancy?...on marriage? Most likely it's a combination of things. And my money's on a leadership/rank-and-file dynamic as a significant piece of it. The most recent numbers around attitudes toward homosexuality point in that direction.

Thoughts?


Recent Entries Filed under Politics:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


interesting.
while streight people are held under the microscope what about Gay and Lesbian couples.
How many of you expressed being in a committed relationship lasted longer then lets say ten years.
I was married and my marriage lasted over 19 years before several stressors caused the marriage to fail.

I had a relationship after that that lasted five years and we agreed when i transitioned to break it off and remain friends that was 7 years ago and we still are friends and living under the same roof.

So i have to ask can Gays and Lesbians do better then Borne again Christians, to be honest based on my experience in the G/L communities i bet Y'all can't.

This is a poor standard to use to justify same sex marriage on. Keep in mind i am all for Universal Marriage among humans that would include multiple partners or group marriages.

whenever the subject of religion comes up in conversations among GLBT people they ether are very negative or very uneasy, like there is a 1200 pound elephant in the room.

Something that needs to be said and it is coming from someone who occupies a special space in all things Christian, the Bible says nothing about women or men with a TS history only their sexual preference. Now that i have said that Gays and Lesbians have Nothing to prove to Christians Their job is not to judge and to be universally accepting and loving as Jesus commanded.

The only thing Gays and Lesbians are obligated to do is be the best humans they can, and practice the same non judgmental and unconditional love and acceptance of their fellow men and woman.


Neither group has anything to prove to the other.

Take care
and
God Bless

Susan Robins

Maybe I missed something. I didn't read the original post as Gays and Lesbians trying to prove to something to Christians nor trying to judge.

I thought Dustin was just pointing out how the one group that bases their entire reason for denying equal marriage, or even civil unions, for us doesn't do any better than anyone else when it comes to keeping their own unions together.

I think of it more as questioning than judging.