Alex Blaze

Just saw Chuck and Larry

Filed By Alex Blaze | May 06, 2008 9:00 AM | comments

Filed in: Entertainment, Marriage Equality
Tags: Adam Sandler, Chuck and Larry, domestic partnership, movies

Has it really been almost a year since Chuck and Larry was released? Oh, my. I remember the mini-controversy over whether or not it was homophobic like it was yesterday.

I just saw it Saturday, over at a friend's apartment here. It wasn't really my choice - I showed up unannounced and he was already watching it.

It's about two straight, male firefighters who get married after a long string of highly contrived circumstances forces them to. One's a family man who's wife just died, the other's a selfish, perpetually adolescent player (who grows up because he meets the right woman), but both were pulled off the front shelf in that warehouse that houses stock characters.

Well, they get DP'd in New York City, discover that they could do hard time for fraud since they're being thoroughly investigated by the city, so they marry in Canada and start to act like a couple. It climaxes in a huge trial where they keep on lying, but in the end tell the truth and are embraced by the gays.

Uh, yeah. And the humor wasn't any less forced than the plot. Even as a non-fan I could see that it wasn't Sandler's best. (Although it was better than the horror that was Click. I saw that two weeks ago, and, oh my, there are some things you can't unwatch.)

As for the homophobia, well, I didn't see it. Yeah, there were the tired gay male stereotypes, but far fewer than in any Margaret Cho or Kathy Griffin routine. And there were a few speeches from the characters after they'd played gay for a while about how hurtful the word "faggot" is and why people should accept the gays.

What I did find offensive, which I remember reading about last year, was Rob Schneider's yellow-face character that looked it came straight out of Breakfast at Tiffany's. It made me uncomfortable in my seat. Rob, you can be an animal, you can be a gigolo (twice), but when you play another race in the most ignorant stereotypes of that race for laughs from white folks, it's offensive.

The whole plot was annoying as well - they were being investigated for "fraudulently" entering a domestic partnership. It was portrayed as something the gays would want investigated and punished with imprisonment - we didn't fight hard all this time for recognition to have someone abuse the privilege.

Honestly, I don't think many people in the community would care, especially considering how many people "fraudulently" enter straight marriages. Not only would I personally be uncomfortable with the state investigating a couple to see if they're having sex and if they "truly" love each other, there's nothing fraudulent about marrying or registering for the material benefits if you're honest with your partner. Unless it's in the case of immigration, no one's going to investigate a straight marriage to see if it's fraudulent or not. Hell, we have dozens of openly fraudulent straight marriages on the covers of grocery store check-out line magazines every day, and no one's calling the cops.

I know, I know, that's just another layer of the contrived plot. But underneath that part of the movie is the idea that gay relationships and anyone exhibiting a sex life outside God-ordained heterosexual marriage is suspect. How can they do that? I bet they're lying!

It seems like a variant of "It's just a phase," "She just needs to find the right man," or "If you just pray hard enough...."

All in all, though, if there was a teenage Adam Sandler fan out there, just one, who decided to stop using the word "faggot" as a result of this film, then... then we have an awful long way to go with the teenage Adam Sandler fan demographic.

Just kidding. I'm sure someone liked it.


Recent Entries Filed under Entertainment:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


"The whole plot was annoying as well - they were being investigated for "fraudulently" entering a domestic partnership. It was portrayed as something the gays would want investigated and punished with imprisonment - we didn't fight hard all this time for recognition to have someone abuse the privilege.

Honestly, I don't think many people in the community would care..."

Well, I'd check that thought against those who would like to see the IRS come down on Thomas Beatie and his family.

On a different note regarding Chuck and Larry: Has there been any explanation as to the change in dialoge between the commercials shown during the theatrical release and the dialoge on the DVD? Specifically, I'm thinking of when, in the supermarket scene, Kevin James shows Adam Sandler the box of tampons and Sandler responds "We're supposed to be gay, not transsexuals." On the DVD (at least the copy of it that my partner rented a few weeks back), the word 'transsexuals' was replaced by 'women.' (I'm assuming that the commercials reflected the dialoge that was actually shown in the theaters.)

You're such a bitch. I saw you had scheduled this yesterday - when I was going to post on it too! We watched the flick this weekend too for the 1st time.

We get along too damn well, Alex. I'd have written the same post you just did. My sentiments exactly.

Not nearly as homophobic as it was made out to be and much more racially insensitive.

Well, they get DP'd in New York City

I read this as "double penetrated" at first, which in my opinion would be a much better movie.

Chris MacDonald-Dennis | May 6, 2008 1:39 PM

Rob Schneider is actually half-Asian; his mother is Filipina. It saddens me even more that he would want to get laughs from hurtful stereotypes that affect at least half of his family.

By the way, to find out who is mixed, go to http://www.mixedfolks.com/

but both were pulled off the front shelf in that warehouse that houses stock characters.

Clever.

Congrats . . . aside from your April Fools' Day post, this is your shortest post yet. Me likey!

Huzzah, Bil! That's pretty crazy!

I agree, That Guy.

Don't know, Kat, but I did see the scene where it was "women." I didn't really notice all that hard....