The rightwing group, Citizens for Good Public Policy (insert eye roll here), have launched a campaign to repeal the recently passed gender identity protection clause in Gainesville, Florida. In January, commissioners voted to include the phrase "gender identity" in the anti-discrimination ordinance that guarantees equal access to housing, employment, public accommodation and credit.
The commercial shows a little girl on a playground walking into a bathroom. She is followed shortly after by a suspicious looking man. A black screen then flashes the words: "your City Commission made this legal."
CGPP says the recently passed protections "will allow sexual predators into public restrooms." Ugh.
Video after the jump...
The petition currently being circulated would bar the city from offering resident protections beyond those included in Florida's Civil Rights Act. The Civil Rights Act does not mention sexual orientation or gender identity. City officials say the broad language of the group's petition would deny discrimination protection to gays, lesbians and bisexuals as well.
Citizens for Good Public Policy, led by Cain Davis (a member of the Alachua County Republican executive committee), has until July 29 to collect 5,581 signatures to place a charter amendment on the 2009 ballot. Davis estimates they need about 2,000 more signatures to get the issue on the ballot. Said Davis
This is not about being against a homosexual agenda, this is about looking out for the people in the city.
When will this disgusting fear mongering end? This is just like the anti-trans "shower scare" tactics used by a Maryland group last year that I blogged about.
Like other fundie groups before them, CGPP is creating an atmosphere of hate that not only furthers their narrow, bigoted viewpoint, but also makes it dangerous and potentially violent for trans and gender variant people living in their community.









Ugh. Of course it's a sweet little blonde white girl too.
DDog | July 24, 2008 2:32 PM
Reply to this comment
I know, DDog. This entire video and webiste made me want to throw up and punch someone all at the same time...
Waymon Hudson | July 24, 2008 2:43 PM
Reply to this comment
Umm, do any of these people realize that little girls are more likely to be sexually abused by someone in their own family - like a dad, uncle, male cousin, etc.? It's pretty shameful that 1 in 3 girls and 1 in 6 boys are sexually abused as children. By straight men, no less. So what this group really needs to do if it actually cares about the children is to ban straight males from public restrooms, and private homes. Fuck off!
Serena Freewomyn | July 24, 2008 8:32 PM
Reply to this comment
But fear and lack of understanding is all they have to work with. I am sad to admit the amount of prejudice I have just had to wait to die off. Once they have an opinion/stereotype/prejudice haters are usually loath to reconsider or change it.
Robert Ganshorn | July 25, 2008 3:38 AM
Reply to this comment
Hi, I am one of the G'ville transdykes who testified to the Commission in January and yes, many (most) of those in opposition were angry, thuggish, fundies from one particular church, The Rock and that church isn't even in Gainesville. In fact this whole opposition movement is being orchestrated by folk frome somewhere else. Literally and figuratively. But even if they get on the ballot we are gearing up to defeat them at the ballot box.
J-Marie
J-Marie | July 25, 2008 4:00 AM
Reply to this comment
I know, that commercial's pretty racist. And maybe if the kids weren't screaming so much it would have more of an effect....
Wait, was that dude meant to be trans? Was he like a transman/pedophile? Or was he a cisman/pedophile who researched non-discrimination acts extensively to find the exact city in which to attack, and then didn't even bother to shave or put on a clean shirt when he went out there?
These people are dumb, but they've got the emotional blackmail thing down. Like Serena points out, they ignore the girls who are sexually molested in their families, and those people who seek to molest in the family use cultural protections of family's privacy to do what they do. And these groups all the while protect the family as a cohesive, safe unit, even when it shouldn't be or isn't.
Talk about distraction politics. Why are they supporting the pedophiles?
Alex Blaze | July 25, 2008 7:39 AM
Reply to this comment
@Alex Blaze
"Talk about distraction politics. Why are they supporting the pedophiles?"
I agree with the rest of your comment about the ridiculous nature of this commercial. However, I think it's important to note a distinction between pedophilia and child molestation, especially in the context of abuse in the family. It is not necessary to have an attraction to pre-pubescent children (pedophilia) or pubescent and post-pubescent adolescents (ephebophila) in order to molest them, and many individuals who have either of these diagnoses do not molest children. "Supporting the pedophiles" actually involves therapy, observation, and treatment. Supporting child molesters, on the other hand, can be done by, as you said, "protect[ing] the family as a cohesive, safe unit, even when it shouldn't be or isn't," among other similar practices. Civil rights for trans people are not among these practices.
"Men in dresses molesting our children" is a red herring and ignores the true sources of child molestation in the US and around the world. It is very saddening to me that individuals and groups who claim to care about children are being taken in by this kind of rhetoric, and spending money to deny civil rights to trans people when there are much better ways to protect children.
DDog | July 25, 2008 8:35 AM
Reply to this comment
I don't understand what's so hard about mounting counter advertising depicting what the public all knows as truth that your more likely to be molested by a man claiming god.Posters of two republican men doing the republican mating foot shuffle in the mens room.Or how about a picture of a Catholic priest and a kid to scare them.Amy
amym440 | July 25, 2008 9:18 AM
Reply to this comment
Great idea, Amy. Fight fire with fire. Show Larry Craig entering the bathroom after another guy enters.
"The Religious Right thinks this is how bathrooms should operate. Do you?"
LOL
I love it how they don't even mention anything trans or even show a trans person going into the bathroom. Instead, it's obviously male what with the stubble.
How about a commercial that shows a woman, a girl and a trans woman all entering the potty at the same time? You still stay outside the door, but soon here three toilets flush and then they exit. "This is how bathrooms are supposed to function. Hysteria over a bathroom should have stopped when we switched to Charmin over Sears and Roebuck."
Bil Browning | July 25, 2008 9:33 AM
Reply to this comment
This ad is so frightening, and it seems like this particular scare tactic might be catching on across the country. I wonder if there's just a rhetorical debt to the recent Focus on the Family campaign, or if Focus is actually actively involved in financing this campaign too? Does anyone know?
Paige Schilt | July 25, 2008 11:07 AM
Reply to this comment
Focus on the Family did help fund the Maryland case I blogged about (the "shower scare" group), but I've looked at current funding for the Gainesville group and they have only raised a few hundred dollars according to their latest contribution filings. As more of their financials come out, I’ll let you know.
I will say that the rhetoric from the commercial and on their website is directly from FOTF and other fundie groups.
Waymon Hudson | July 25, 2008 11:22 AM
Reply to this comment
Good point, DDog.
Serena Freewomyn | July 25, 2008 12:42 PM
Reply to this comment