Eric Marcus

I'm In Love! Why Can't I Tell Anyone?

Filed By Eric Marcus | October 19, 2008 9:00 AM | comments

Filed in: Living
Tags: bisexual, coming out in high school, in love with a guy, secret, what if someone I know is gay

hey eric: i have a few problems and lots of questions so this will probably end up being lengthy. i guess i'll start with my story. i am a guy and i have a boyfriend and we've been together for six months. no one, no friends or family members know we are together. everyone just thinks that we are close friends; we are.

i'm not gay because i still find certain girls attractive but i don't know if i can say i'm bi because this is the first time i've ever had feelings this strong for another guy. in fact i've never even felt like this before not even for another girl and this is definitely more than a platonic crush.

i've read your book "what if someone i know is gay" about eight times. it helped me a lot about figuring out how i actually feel about my boyfriend. i was a freshman in high school when i first realized i was curious and i am now a junior and totally in love ( i realize love is a strong word for a sixteen year old but i know exactly how i feel).

the thing is i'm ready to start telling close friends about us but he isn't. i've tried talking to him about it and he is still scared and nervous about telling people in public. we are just like best friends. we are never intimate or hold hands or anything.

i know neither of us are ready to tell family members but i feel like six months together with no one knowing is enough time. do you have some suggestions on what i could say to him to make him feel more comfortable? or do you think i should wait until he's ready?

Dear Totally In Love,

Being in love is a powerful thing and I would never question that your feelings are genuine. I remember being just a little older than you are now and feeling those feelings myself. And it was amazing and a little terrifying. So there's no need to persuade me that your feelings for your boyfriend are very, very real. I completely understand.

Now, about your boyfriend's wish to keep your relationship secret. You're going to have to honor his wishes. This is not the kind of thing you can force, especially since the implications of coming out at school are pretty serious. If you tell a few of your friends and ask them to keep it secret, at least one of them is likely to tell someone else and even if they ask them to keep it a secret within no time a lot of people at school will know. And then before long your parents and your boyfriend's parents will likely find out, too. I had this happen to me at college and it was very upsetting (fortunately, I told my mother before the news got to her).

So unless you're certain that no one at school would react badly and that your parents would all be supportive, you can't reassure your boyfriend that everything will be okay if everyone knows the truth about your relationship. There's a lot of risk here, so even though you would like to tell people how happy you are and that you love someone the way you love your boyfriend, you're going to have to keep this secret for now. Even if your boyfriend agreed with your wish to be more open, which he doesn't, you would have to very carefully consider your circumstances--how your classmates would react, how your parents would react--before telling anyone.

I know that this is not ideal. It's not fair. And it's not easy. But we don't yet live in a world where same-sex love is universally celebrated (not even close!).

One person I suggest you talk to is a counselor at school if there's a counselor there you can trust with this secret. Or, if you can talk openly with your mother or father, that's something you could consider as well, but that depends on your relationship with your parents, how easily you can talk to them, and what their views are about same-sex relationships. (I would want to know more about your parents before recommending that you talk to them about this.)

It's important for you to have someone you can talk to other than your boyfriend about your feelings for him and your frustrations at having to keep secret your relationship. It's not good to be isolated (which I'm sure you already know).

All best, Eric


Recent Entries Filed under Living:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


Very good advice, Eric. When one teen partner starts forcing the other out of the closet, it can lead to a horrible conclusion and heartbreak. I know this myself.

Hello teenager:

I was forced "out" at 14. That relationship lasted 3 months after that. I already got a lot of hell. However, let me tell you point blank. this can mean knife wounds and hockey sticks against the head.

Your life and his are more important than declaring your love openly.

I am lucky. My dad is gay. However, chances are that your parents are not. My best friend, who has a closeted lesbian sister; told his parents he was gay. The constantly degrade him; she has her mortgage, phone, and car payment paid by their parents.

Patience is a difficult path and if you can respect your boyfriends wishes you may reap the benefits. I've been with my husband (yes, husband) for five years. We married in July.Some things are worth waiting for.

Patience; if it is meant to be, it will turn out.
Patience is your ally.

Remember Lawrence King
Remember Matthew Shepard
Remember Brandon Tina

Zechariah Aloysius Hillyard

Yeah, if he wants to take that risk, it's his choice. But if his bf doesn't, then it's not his choice to be making.