Matt Comer

A salvation for Baptists?

Filed By Matt Comer | August 31, 2009 4:00 PM | comments

Filed in: Living
Tags: Albert Mohler, Jimmy Carter, Southern Baptist Convention

At the gathering of the Baptist World Alliance in The Netherlands in mid-August, Baptists from around the globe gathered to celebrate and remember the 400th anniversary of their founding. Among the topics for discussion was what is, perhaps, the Christian church's greatest social and moral dilemma in modern times: LGBT people in the life of the church.

During the meeting, two pastors civilly debated the issue, reflecting a theological divide as great as the geographic distance between them. American pastor Scott Stearman and Nigerian pastor Ayo Gbode conversation was a shining example of the theological diversity of the Baptist faith.

Stearman, of St. Louis' Kirkwood Baptist Church, admonished the gathering. After touring nearby Amsterdam and noting the advertisements for the city's Pride festival, he said, "We Baptists cannot act like this is going to go away. We've got to discuss it."

In agreement with this point alone, perhaps, Gbode said, "The church can no longer stand aloof and believe that some angelic host from heaven will come and cleanse the earth of this gangrene of a behavior called homosexuality. The church must respond, but her response must be ethical."

Gbode, pastor of Christ Baptist Church in Gbagada, Nigeria, said the church must work against "the homosexual agenda" and "always be willing to assist [gays] overcome attraction to the same sex."

Stearman disagreed. The Associated Baptist Press reports:

But Stearman said scientific evidence makes it increasingly difficult to affirm the idea that sexual orientation is a changeable trait. He drew a parallel between how science and changing social standards altered Christians' interpretations of the Bible's passages on slavery and how emerging scientific and social evidence may cause Christians to take another look at what they have, in the past, viewed as unambiguous scriptural injunctions on homosexuality.

"Our understanding of sexual relationships, of monogamy, polygamy and the status of women has changed radically since the Bible was first compiled in the 4th century," he said.

"This change is not in spite of the Bible, but in fact because of the Bible," Stearman continued. "For while there are many texts rooted in systems of injustice that we find abhorrent [such as slavery and gender inequality], the teachings of Jesus prompt us inexorably to another level of freedom."

Regardless of the outcome of this conversation, Stearman's and Gbode's graceful and friendly fellowship in the face of theological disagreement is overshadowed by a very un-Baptist action taken by the Baptist World Alliance more than a decade ago.

In 1994, the Baptist World Alliance approved a resolution affirming a theological view that homosexual behavior was incompatible with Scripture. Although no one is willing to label these statements and resolutions for what they are, such creeds (also passed by state Baptist conventions and the national Southern Baptist Convention) are antithetical to Baptist faith. The divisions caused by these documents are at the very heart of what threatens to tear the faith apart.

In early August, only a couple weeks after announcing his departure from the Southern Baptist Convention, President Jimmy Carter spoke to a gathering of the New Baptist Covenant, a moderate Baptist organization he helped found. There he said divisions among believers, such as those regarding homosexuality, the place of women and abortion, are "like a cancer that is metastasizing in the body of Christ."

Carter's honorable attempt to save traditional Baptist faith inside the Southern Baptist Convention is falling on deaf ears.

Albert Mohler, president of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Ken., also addressed the current state of Baptist faith recently. Speaking to fellow Baptists, faculty and students, Mohler said the faith has been met with an unprecedented challenge.

"The Southern Baptist Convention is either going to become younger or dead," Mohler said, according to The Associated Press. "Here we have a big issue; we're losing at least two-thirds of our young people somewhere along the line between adolescence and adulthood. A generation that has reduced religion and Christianity to what is called moralistic, therapeutic deism -- believing that God basically wants them to do well and to do right and to be happy."

This impending death of the Southern Baptist Convention (which I briefly discussed at InterstateQ.com last week) is marked by the faith's rapid departure from its historic roots.

Ex-Gay Watch's Eugene Wagner reports:

Centuries ago, the Baptist church was founded on the principle of freedom of conscience. According to Baptist belief, individual Christians are fully competent to study the Bible for themselves and to seek guidance from God (the "priesthood of the believer"); consequently, Baptists of all stripes strongly opposed the adoption of any formal creeds, save perhaps "Ain't nobody but Jesus going to tell me what to believe." To this day, many Baptist churches maintain this commitment to the autonomy of the local church and the individual believer.

Since 2000, however, the Southern Baptist Church has departed sharply from its roots. Although the SBC's updated Baptist Faith & Message (BF&M) statement is not formally labeled a creed, all references to individual conscience have either been eliminated or redefined to effectively outlaw dissent on any matter outlined in the BF&M. Southern Baptist congregations must now strictly interpret the Bible according to the positions detailed in the BF&M, and the Bible itself has been elevated to a position once reserved for Christ alone. Churches that even appear to be deviating from the party line may be subject to disciplinary hearings.

What is the result of these "disciplinary hearings," you ask? Ex-communication.

North Carolina's State Baptist Convention became one of the first local or state Baptist associations to disfellowship fellow congregations. In 1994, they booted Chapel Hill's Binkley Baptist and Raleigh's Pullen Baptist. And, in recent years, the State Convention has adopted more stringent rules expediting an involuntary exit for churches refusing to conform to "resolutions" condemning homosexuality as sinful.

In Texas, just this month, a professor at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary resigned his position at the school, rather than be forced to resign from his membership at Broadway Baptist Church, an LGBT-inclusive congregation disfellowshipped by the Southern Baptist Convention this summer.

Mohler laments at the increasing loss of Southern Baptist membership. But he and other Southern Baptist leaders, as well as others across the world, take no pause when chopping off a thumb here or a pinky there and, soon, legs and arms of the Body of Christ.

There is only one possible salvation for Baptists: Adherence to the principles and guiding doctrines that have defined their faith for four centuries: soul freedom, the liberty of conscience and the priesthood of all believers; fellowship in the face of theological diversity and disagreement; and the autonomy of the local church.

If Baptists return to these historic roots, they will once again experience growth. But something else will happen, too. These principles have made the way for progressive and inclusive growth of faith for centuries. If Baptists return to them, they will find their faith growing in acceptance and love for their LGBT brothers and sisters in Christ. The Gospel commands it.


Recent Entries Filed under Living:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


Excellent! Thanks for this. I'll be sure to follow this much more closely now!

Being a recovering baptist, I can remember realizing very early (like around 10 or 12 years old) that India and China are two of the most populated countries in the world..and I cannot be believe that a God who created the world would let all those people go to hell because they don't believe a man was nailed to the cross 2000 years ago. If you can't believe that fundamental notion of theology, then the rest of the baptist teaching really falls short too. Its no wonder young people are leaving this church...like never before younger generations are so tuned in to the world, its cultures, and its diversity.

For many of the younger set, Baptists are quickly becoming the new Mormons/Jehovah's Witnesses. They're increasingly seen as a fringe conservative group instead of a church witnessing to the love of Christ. They're being defined by everything they consider wrong instead of the joy of Christ. They are turning into the Pharisees while the Mormons and Jehovah's Witnesses back them up in the Sadducees and Essenes roles.

Good to see that this dialog is taking place at all and to see it happening in a peaceful manner in some places is a good thing.
I'm certainly not Christian but the world would be a far better place if the Christians who do it stopped hammering at us. Barring that that happening I am left in a position where i have to be pleased that so many Christian institutions and organizations are collapsing and shrinking. That may be the only way to get them to be less of a danger to the rest of us.

I am a pastor's son, church organist, choir leader and attended a Bible College for a short while, ALL the time knowing I was gay. It was a frightening time. One of my first homosexual experiences happened at the college. I cried many tears asking God to change me. I can look through my year book and recognize many students and some teachers who were closeted gay people. When the church preaches the love of Christ instead of hate, they will find more young people willing to join. Love is Christ message, not hate. He welcomes everyone. Can we do any better than to be Christlike?

Religion is the enemy.

The baptist, mormon and catholic cults are the WaffenSS of the right. They used Obama's bigoted war cry of 'gawd's in the mix' to crush same sex marriage in California.

Isn't it interesting that normally most of the fighters on both sides of a war pray to their Gods to win that war?