Rev Irene Monroe

Jamaica's Gay Underground Christians

Filed By Rev Irene Monroe | March 17, 2010 4:30 PM | comments

Filed in: Living, Politics
Tags: J-FLAG, Jamaica, lesbian, LGBT, MCC

Sometime in the late hours of Saturday night the call will come in. Philbert (not his real name), like many of his Christian lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ) buddies, wait anxiously for the call in order to know the time and place of the van pickup, and where it'll drop them off to a safe and secluded place for Sunday worship. Last week's worship service was in Montego Bay, just 50 miles from Negril's Grand Lido, one of the flagship resorts in Jamaica, where Philbert works the night shift at the bar. This week Philbert hopes for a closer worshipping space, perhaps a safe space in Gales Valley, just 40 miles from work.

Every Sunday, Philbert and his friends have to worship in a different space. The risk is too high if it's found out they're queer.

"My experience as a gay man living in Jamaica is one which is marked by periodic incidences of abuse, both verbal and physical. I have lost count of the number of times I have been verbally abused, called 'battyman,' 'chi-chi,' 'sodomite,' 'dirty battybwoy,'" an unnamed gay man shares on the Jamaican Forum of Lesbians, All-Sexuals and Gays (J-Flag) in 2003.

When Jamaica's leading gay rights activist, Brian Williamson, was murdered in his home in June 2004, multiple knife wounds savagely mutilated his body. A Human Rights Watch researcher witnessed the crime, reporting a crowd gathered after the killing, rejoicing and saying, "Battyman [Jamaican slang for homosexual], he get killed!" Others celebrated Williamson's murder, laughing and calling out, "Let's get them one at a time," "That's what you get for sin," and "Let's kill all of them." Some sang, "Boom bye bye," a line from renowned Jamaican reggae artist Buju Banton's then popular anti-gay song about killing and burning gay men. (Banton has a long history of advocating the killing of LGBTQ people in his lyrics yet he was nominated for a Grammy in 2009 for his album Rasta Got Soul).

In 2005 a gay man was harassed at the beach, and a mob pursued him. To avoid the homophobic wrath of the mob he ran into the sea and drowned.

In 2007 a pastor's church was attacked by an angry mob on Easter Sunday because of the presence of people accused of being homosexuals were at a funeral service he performed earlier in the week.

And in November 2008, Rev. Richard Johnson, one of the leading Anglican priests on the island, was found nude and stabbed 25 times, in the rectory of St. Jude's Anglican Church in Kingston, because he was thought to be gay.

Homophobia is so intense in Jamaica and goes unchallenged that people who speculate about who's LGBTQ, can easily plot to kill them, and unabashedly announce their intent with impunity, because the police won't protect Jamaica's LGBTQ citizens from mob led murders and violence; they instead incite the country's homophobic frenzy by either being present and inactive during these assaults or by following and watching them all the time.

In 2010 nothing has changed. So when the van arrives on Sunday morning before the island has risen, Philbert and friends stealthy pack into it and off they go.

Metropolitan Community Church (MCC) provides most of the vans, helping these underground Christians find sacred space. Sunshine Cathedral (MCC), in Ft. Lauderdale, FL, has chartered a Sunshine Cathedral mission church in Jamaica. The mission church is active in several cities in Jamaica and has monthly island-wide meetings at changing locations.

Jamaican LGBTQ Christians welcomes MCC's outreach ministry to them, but the church is viewed by many of the islanders as an abomination.

In a letter to the editor of the Jamaica Observer titled "Wilson's homosexual theology ain't right." JM Fletcher of St. Andrew expressed his outrage:

"I note with interest an article written by an American lesbian preacher Nancy Wilson, who is bent on crusading and promoting her chosen lifestyle. My concern about homosexuals is that if allowed to run unchecked they move from their outward recruitment drive to deliberate thrust of their lifestyle on the rest of us. This can be seen in how they are moving into every segment of the community - even the church - to try to perpetuate their lifestyle." Fletcher states.

"If Ms Wilson is an American, why is she so desperate to start a foundation for homosexuality in other countries? She cares nothing for the culture of other nations? She might ask us soon to allow a man to marry a pig! Because from a Christian perspective, what would be the difference? Both are an abomination to God, yet homosexuality happens and bestiality too - if one is made legal, so should the other, and the homosexual church can allow for a man to marry a dog - if he finds the companionship of a dog preferable to that of humans... For the pastors claiming to be Christians who are approving of such churches, I repeat, they are not of God."

The Reverend Elder Nancy Wilson is unquestionably a woman of God, and was the first pastor of MCC, Boston in the 70's. Rev. Wilson is now the Presiding Elder and Moderator of the Universal Fellowship of MCC, a global denomination with now 300 churches in 28 countries. Founded by Troy Perry, an excommunicated gay Pentecostal minister, MCC is a radically inclusive church opened to all people, regardless of theological background, gender, sexual orientation, race, ethnicity, age, or ability, and is leading force in the development of queer theology. (In the 80's MCC saved my life, welcoming me as a member of MCC, NYC).

In April 2008, Cambridge City Councilor Ken Reeves, the son of Jamaican immigrants, traveled to Kingston, Jamaica to join Wilson and Rev. Pat Bumgartner of MCC, NYC in a demonstration denouncing violence against LGBTQ citizens on the island. And in June of that year Reeves put together the panel, "Jamaica: Yes, Problems- A Visit to Homophobia," held at Christ Episcopal Church in Harvard Square, to seek out solutions.

But in country with no federal hate crime bill, police enforcement and church to protect LGBTQ Jamaicans solutions can't found.

So in the meantime, Philbert and his friends wait anxiously for the call on Saturday night to be told where their sacred space will be. And when the van arrives on Sunday morning before the island has risen Philbert and friends stealthy pack into it and off they go.


Recent Entries Filed under Politics:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


There's some great work being done in Jamaica to empower LGBTQ Jamaicans. Thanks for sharing, Rev.!

I was married in Negril and I liked the people there. Well, before I was about to make my gender change I went down there on last time in Feb 2002. Some nice lady painted my nails and I strolled about on the private grounds of an all inclusive resort and got the nastiest looks. I knew better than to go into town, that would have been pushing my luck.

One guy looked at me like he wanted to rip my head off. The only thing preventing him from doing so was his job. Jobs are not easy to come by in J.A. The interest rate was 30% on a home loan. People build their houses as they can afford to buy building materials. So you see lots of partially complete houses made of cement block.
hardly anyone gets a loan, it just costs to much.

I don't undertsand the level of hatred towards queer folk there. It one thing to disagree, but I really felt unsafe.

I wish them all the best down there. There are some good people there. I guess I need to find another place to vacation. Key West. My backyard.

Best of luck to them all I had some of my best times there. And married a beautiful woman who is no longer with us.

Since it is St. Patty's day I thought I would mention they do drink guiness in JA but they drink it warm. As in sitting in the scorching sun all day warm. I couldn't get mine down. I switched to a cold heineken or as my local friend there called it "the green beer".

I was there many years ago and felt unsafe. The engine behind Jamaica politics is religion and money. Homosexuality is against the law and buggery (anal sex) carries a sentence of 7 years in prison.
I am sure that MCC thinks they are saving the world through preaching the love of Jesus, but that kind of missionary Christian colonialism only serves to antagonize the status quo of Jamaica. LGBT's lives could be put in further danger by MCC evangelizing making homosexuality visible..There are no easy answers.

There is only problem with Charles Merrill's comment about missionary Christian colonialism: MCC was invited by local Jamaicans to help them organize and become stronger. They were being killed when they tried not to antagonize the status quo and realized that the only way things would change was to gain strength. MCC supports the indigenous movement and is not trying to convert anyone.

I can't imagine what life is like there. I always wanted to visit Jamaica as a tourist paradise, but after years of anti-LGBT hate, I doubt I'd ever be willing to set foot on the island and feel safe and comfortable. It'd be like vacationing at a skinhead retreat.

you dont have to be afraid...there are no antigays in tourists areas...
.only in urban areas
Antigays are everywhere even in english parliament read below

Anti gays in english parliament
The Tories were embroiled in a furious row over lesbian and gay rightson Saturday after the shadow home secretary, Chris Grayling, was secretly taped suggesting that people who ran bed and breakfasts in their homes should "have the right" to turn away homosexual couples.

The comments, made by Grayling last week to a leading centre-right thinktank, drew an angry response from gay groups and other parties, which said they were evidence that senior figures in David Cameron's party still

Abdullah Aziz | May 7, 2010 11:16 AM

I beleive that Jamaica is even more homophobic then Russia. And that place is filled with murderous nazis

I think that Jamaica's first sucessful pride march in April 2010 was a great leap forward and I can only hope that there are many more great leaps to come.


This article is misleading because most of the murders cited here were inter-relationship killing and NOT homophobic killings. The persons were killed by persons that were romantically involved with.