Alex Blaze

Andrew Shirvell's campaign against a college student: What hatred looks like

Filed By Alex Blaze | September 30, 2010 1:00 PM | comments

Filed in: Living
Tags: Andrew Shirvell, Chris Armstrong, Michigan, university of michigan

Michigan assistant attorney general Andrew Shirvell, whose claim to fame is his bizarre campaign against the University of Michigan'sshrivell2.jpg openly gay student body president, is a perfect example of hatred. After he started getting attention for his website devoted to picking apart Armstrong's life, I checked out his website, which is full of the hallmarks of hatred - nitpicking, obsession, double standards (every time a gay person speaks, it's "harassment"; when a homophobe speaks it's "exercising their First Amendment rights"), hyperbolic language, and hypocrisy.

Hatred doesn't only go in one direction; there are plenty of liberals who have plenty of hatred for the right. I think we're witnessing a period of time when liberal hatred is higher than it has been in a while, what with all the frustration towards the Democratic Congress and the president, and it's toxic and does nothing to help anyone. That's not to say that it outweighs the hatred the right has for everyone else (if there were a Hating Olympics, conservatives would win the gold in every event), but it's important to realize that our criticisms of others are usually based on degree and not quality, that if we're going to "call out" someone else for something we don't like we should be completely willing to examine our own faults as well.

But I wanted to post on Shirvell because his site is filled with so many of those comments that I see on the internet, especially on traditional media sources' stories on LGBT people, that I usually chalk up to the internet just vomiting. It's easy to forget that there are actual people in front of their computers, with families and jobs and hobbies and tastes and pets, typing something like "If GOD wanted man to commit SODOMY He wouldn't have cleraly condemmed it in the BIBLE!!" The internet hasn't brought us closer to one another in the most productive way possible - it forces us to interact with people who we can't see and don't know, eliminating any possibility of us putting ourselves in their shoes. It has, in that sense, isolated people.

So it is nice to see the person behind some of those comments. This one just happens to be a successful attorney.

Going back to Shirvell's hatred of Chris Armstrong and gay people generally, here's a photo he spends over 1700 words deconstructing along with some other, more minor complaints:

Chris + Oltean Disrespecting African-American DPS Officer, March '10.jpg

He accuses Armstrong of being "disrespectful to police" based on that photo, not omitting the fact that Shirvell assumes that the officer is African American and accuses Armstrong of being racist. It reminds me of all those time rightwingers have taken a single photo of Obama out of context to show that he's bowing to the wrong leader, being disrespectful to the wrong world leader, or checking out a woman. They work themselves into a lather over those photos, not even bothering to check the context or video to see what actually happened outside of that split-second in time in ways that appear humorous to outsiders because we're not looking at the photo with hatred and therefore we don't see the same thing.

In this picture I see someone looking at a phone near an officer, that's it, but then I don't hate Chris Armstrong like Andrew Shirvell does.

Just in his most recent blog posts, he writes about how police went to a party Armstrong was at because of alcohol and noise, calling it a "SCANDAL," as if no other college party has ever been too noisy or had alcohol. In another recent post, he takes a sentence Armstrong made in a speech about how college is about "self-discovery" and accused him of promoting self-absorption recruiting "your sons and daughters to join the homosexual 'lifestyle'" (lifestyle is already the word they made up to deride gay people, so does putting it in scarequotes cancel out that effect?). In yet another post, he calls Armstrong a "Klansman" because some drunks at a nightclub "glared," "shouted," and took his anti-gay sign away from him (if his account is to be believed). Armstrong wasn't even at the club, so I don't really see the connection other than that Shirvell assumed the people who glared/shouted at him were "homosexuals," therefore "supporters of Armstrong," but that's the mind of a hater.

This man is clearly sick, and to be sick doesn't mean that he's evil but it does mean that he shouldn't have his hands on the levers of power in Michigan's criminal justice system.


Recent Entries Filed under Living:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


The Assistant Attorney General of Michigan is stalking, harrassing, targeting, scapegoating a college student at his own alma mater.

The Attorney General does not find these behaviours as demeaning the office.

The Prosecutor Ms Hennessey does find that Michigan can now be crossed off the list of states that can be considered part of western Civilisation, as these actions or failures to act by its officials, risky to the target of the smears, is clearly cosidered within the realm of professional conduct by its highest law enforcement official.

Think of it, a Peronista Presidente of Argentina is more pro civil rights than the highest law enforcement official of a US State....and tehy still scream "unfair" and "our relious rights are violated" when their ability to destroy us in impeded....

Michigan: Where a gay teen cannot grow up to be student body president, according to the AG's office

ONLY Christians have the right to free speech, because it is a God given, Natural Law right as granted in the most Christian documents called the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. Only Christians have unfettered free speech in the classroom, the workplace and the public square. If you disagree with Christian speech you are discriminating against Christians and are un-American.

You will be assimilated, resistance is futile.

(sometimes in the Midwest, this is how it really works, and how idiots like this get away with it)

Why is Pee Wee Herman so mad?

Kathy Padilla | September 30, 2010 4:29 PM

Fixed that:

Andrew Shirvell's campaign against a college student: What self hatred looks like

Can't afford a vacation in Jamaica or Uganda?
There's always Michigan!
Buju Banton would feel right at home there

I see his blog is now only open to invited readers. I'm hoping that's because Blogger is investigating him for TOS violation / hate speech. I'm sure I wasn't the only one to click the "report blog" button when I started reading his drivel. Maybe we can at least muzzel him on one front.

As a resident of Michigan myself, my first reaction to this story believe it or not was one of relief in that Mike Cox the Attorney General who was running for Governor was defeated in the primary. It is very clear, which is what I suspected, that Mike Cox likely shares the views of Andrew Shirvell but does not dare to show it as openly because it would be a problem politically. So if there is an upside to the entire story it is that Cox will not be Governor at least right away.
However, it is very clear there is something very wrong in the Attorney Generals office in Michigan. Add to this the fact the AG for Michigan has joined in the lawsuit to block the Prop 8 injunction along with several other states, claiming the Federal Government does not have a right to stop a State from saying who can get married, and a clearer picture comes forward of the situation in Michigan. As a state that is struggling with high unemployment, and a stalemated government it becomes clear that the ubber right wingers are alive and active here still. Perhaps in addition to high tax rates and an economy that was overly dependent upon the auto industry, it is the rampant bigotry of some in this state that also make it less desirable as a home for new business. I have joked for some time that I live in an area which joining the Tea Party is a move to the left, and with the example of Andrew Shirvell, and Mike Cox you can see that bigotry and hate while claiming it is in the name of God is alive and well in Michigan is no understatement.