Jesse Monteagudo

A Short History of Physique Magazines

Filed By Jesse Monteagudo | February 11, 2011 12:00 PM | comments

Filed in: Media
Tags:

I saw my first physique magazine when I was 13 years old (1966), in a newsstand in downtown Miami. Though I did not yet know what I was, I knew that I found other men attractive, and I was instinctively drawn to the magazines' models, who were completely naked from the back or tastefully covered with a posing strap up front.

tomorrows-man.jpg

Of course having a 13-year old looking at naked men was the last thing the old man who ran the stand wanted, and he was quick to chase me away every time he caught me looking at the magazines (which happened quite often). Still, what little I saw confirmed what I already knew: that, at its best, the male body is the most beautiful thing on God's green Earth. Coming from a family and a culture that claimed men were ugly, it was an epiphany.

I was not the only gay man whose life was changed by physique magazines. In its 1945-1970 heyday, male mags influenced a generation of men who came of age in the crucial decades that followed World War II.

your-physique.jpg"By the end of the 1950s," wrote the author(s) of Completely Queer: The Gay and Lesbian Encyclopedia, "physique magazines were arguably the most openly - and self-affirmingly - gay male publications available to a wide American audience."

According to F. Valentine Hooven, author of Beefcake: The Muscle Magazines of America 1950-1970, "those little physique magazines were not just an aspect of gay culture; they virtually were gay culture." For many gay men, wrote Hooven, "it was their first awareness that they were not alone, the first contact with others of their own kind." Physique Pictorial consistently outsold homophile publications like ONE and the Mattachine Review: To quote Hooven, by the mid-50s "Physique Pictorial and Tomorrow's Man routinely sold over 40,000 copies each," while ONE magazine, at its height (1955), enjoyed a circulation of just 3,500.

The father of physique magazines was Bob Mizer (1922-1992). In 1945 Mizer started the Athletic Model Guild in Los Angeles as a modeling agency for male body-builders. Mizer, a self-taught photographer, recruited and photographed the models, carefully listing their vital statistics along with their real names and ages. Mizer sold his photos by mail, advertising them in men's magazines.

physique-pictorial.jpgBy 1951 Mizer's catalog was so extensive that he began to collect his photos and sell them in a magazine format. Thus began Physique Pictorial. The first publication of its kind, Physique Pictorial showcased a generation of male pinups and bodybuilders, including the recently-deceased Jack LaLanne, "Little" Joe Dallesandro, Steve "Hercules" Reeves, and Mickey Hargitay (the husband of Jayne Mansfield and the father of Mariska Hargitay). Physique Pictorial also showcased the art of George Quaintance, Tom of Finland and "Art-Bob."

Physique Pictorial became a hit with thousands of men, and it was soon joined by a slew of imitators who hoped its success would rub off on them. Soon newsstands carried titles like the Grecian Guild Pictorial, Adonis, Young Adonis, Body Beautiful, and Tomorrow's Man. Chicago's leather king Chuck Renslow jumped on the physique bandwagon with Kris Studios and its publications Triumph and Mars, which became showcases for Renslow's lover, the late, great artist Etienne (Dom Orejudos).

Not surprisingly, physique magazines faced constant attacks from censors, who would not allow "obscene" material through the mail. Mizer served time in prison for "obscenity" and, if we may believe Thom Fitzgerald's 1999 movie Beefcake, pimping out his models to discerning customers. Renslow and his partners were indicted by the Justice Department for "excessive genital delineation." Publishers went through great lengths to avoid similar mishaps. There was no full-frontal nudity - which made the posing pouch synonymous with beefcake magazines - and no body hair; and even exposed buttocks were controversial.

grecian-guild-pictorial.jpgThough most of the physique magazines' readers were gay men, the mags themselves were never "gay." Instead, Mizer and his colleagues pretended that they published their magazines to promote physical fitness, art, or a so-called "Greek Revival" movement. Grecian Guild Pictorial went so far as to publish a "creed" that pledged "allegiance to my native land... I seek a sound body in a sound mind that I may be a complete man; I am a Grecian."

Models posed in historic-artistic settings that evoked Classical Greece, Imperial Rome, Aztec Mexico or the American West. Since in our society male-male contact is only justified under the cover of violence, models were often shown wrestling, which led to a whole new subgenre. Even so, as time went by the mags became more implicitly gay, and though the photos tried to retain the illusion of art and health, the drawings became deliberately campy and suggestive.

What effect did physique magazines have on gay liberation? According to the authors of Completely Queer, "Mizer was never directly associated with gay and lesbian activism, but his effect on the development of a gay male consciousness was immeasurable. As early as the 1950s, he began urging readers of his publications to demand their rights, join homophile organizations, and fight police entrapment and censorship." Certainly Mizer's war against censorship led to wider dissemination of information about homosexuality, which in turn inspired many of us to come out of our closets and to become active in the homophile and gay activist movements.

By the time I came out of the closet (1973), physique magazines were a thing of the past, victims of their own success. Full-frontal male nudity was no longer "obscene," and publications like Drum and Vector soon proclaimed what the beefcake mags could not admit; that they published photos of naked men to please other men.

Still, I never lost my interest in physique magazines, both for their own sake and as an important part of gay social and cultural history. Happily, publishers like Taschen have preserved some of the physique magazines' best - including, most notably, Taschen's three-volume Complete Physique Pictorial. Mizer himself continued to publish Physique Pictorial, as a semi-annual digest of old and new photos, until 1991. Mizer died in 1992, and his Athletic Model Guild soon followed suit.


Recent Entries Filed under Media:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


Thanks for this informative memory-laden post. I discovered these mags when I was 11 or 12, and shared your frustration because of the oversight of a rail-thin, hawk-nose, gray crew-cutted, tall man named Mr. Denny. Whether that was his first or last name remains a mystery. Mr. Denny stood watch over the magazines at Hyman's Books in Des Moines, Iowa. the "adult" publications were shelved high up, so it was obvious that I was trying to look at male flesh. The glare from Mr. D's large eyes could be felt on the back of my neck, and that was enough to make me shift my gaze to the items lower on the stand. If somebody actually reached for a mag that was obviously not in his age range, Mr. D would gently murmur something to make him stop. A second offense involved a closer approach with a warning hand but no contact. And anybody with the temerity to make a third attempt was told, firmly but quietly, to leave the store.

Though Mr. Denny kept me from the physique mags, he gave a hint of a smile when I picked up Paul Krassner's amazing REALIST, or EVERGREEN REVIEW, took my money, and pressed the change into my palm with long, steely fingers. He knew that those were more subversive on my morals than photos of men in posing straps would be, but they were legal. And I think he knew they were what I could actually use to expand my mind and horizons.

Hyman's closed long ago. I wonder sometimes what became of Mr. Denny. He seemed old when I was under surveillence but probably wasn't as ancient as I thought.

David Johnson | March 9, 2011 12:04 AM

I am writing a book-length history of physique magazines and would be interested in talking to anyone who remembers them when they were on newstands. I'm reachable at dkjohns@me.com.

Thanks Jesse. Fascinating piece on this aspect of our history. I'm just a bit young for physique mag. memories, but your article and gregory browns comment brought me back to the my own first furtive glances, and then shaking hands when I purchased my first Playgirls in the mid-1970's

Larry Jurrist | February 12, 2011 1:41 PM

Great to see you in print again, Jesse.

I bought these magazines too from about 12 on, and spent many a happy hour with them and my right hand.

Since I grew up in what became the East Village of Manhattan, the newsstand guys didn't seem to care and let me leaf through them, as long as I always bought something. I was once stopped by a NYC cop on a subway platform who saw me looking at one I had just bought and confiscated it.

A small correction, Tomorrow's Man was the first of these mags (Glenn Bishop was the star), Physique Pictorial came out later.

Physique Pictorial always had the equivalent of thumbnails in its back pages, and among them is one James Hinderycks of Seattle (yes, our Jimi Hendrix) and Dan White, who later murdered Harvey Milk, whose picture is just shirt off in white pants.

Lots of the Physique Pictorial models were real rough trade, and many ended up in jail and/or committing terrible crimes.

Marc, I share with you the memories of buying Playgirl - I want to say furtively, but how can you do that when you have to hand the magazine to the clerk and pay for it?

My main method for the purchase was to pick up the salacious magazine along with at least one other and put it at the bottom. And of course I'm quite sure that convinced a clerk that all was well.

I didn't have a Mr. Denny to watch over me, but I was already in my 20s when I began to (somewhat openly) enjoy naked or near-naked men.