Caitlin Breedlove

One Queer Madisonian Reflects on Day 14 of the WI State Capitol Occupation

Filed By Caitlin Breedlove | March 01, 2011 11:30 AM | comments

Filed in: Politics, The Movement
Tags: class benefits, International, Intersectionality, Protests, Wisconsin

I grew up in Madison, WI, and I would be the first to admit I did not think that a town that has mostly been known for its comfortable arm-chair union-wisconsin-protest.jpgliberal majority and the power they wield could do this. My family would be the first to tell you about how frustrating it has been to live there and try to be part of addressing root causes of racism and poverty, when the overwhelming emotion of the white, middle-class majority is guilt, or overt resentment, to concrete change and justice for oppressed people.

However, 14 days ago something different happened in Madison. Consider the quote from my life-long friend, Twyla Clark, on the ground in Madison this week:

One thing everyone should know is all the different kinds of people who are here with us, who are us. People meditating; teachers who shut down the Madison Public School District for 4 days, who when they had to return to work had parents standing outside the next day holding signs that said: 'I am here for Ms. Butler', and 'I am here for Mr. Jones', representing them; Vets and cops in uniforms; 800 students who walked out from a local high school; an entire March of Librarians, and children, children, so many children and families."

This is not a reflection of some vague notion of "coalitional" movement building - this is people who are very different from each other, want different things, and who have a common interest. This is a recognition that the fight over the consolidation of wealth, resources, land, air, and the rights to our own bodies is being waged between less than 5% of the global population and... the rest of us. That means all the categories of people that Twyla named above, and more. There is no human being not affected.

What does the fight in Madison mean for LGBTQ folks? Why should we all be paying attention, no matter where we live?

First, remember the part of the bill in Wisconsin that has gotten the most attention has been the part about collective bargaining, which is very important. However, the impact of this bill for poor people (particularly in relation to Medicaid and Medicare) is huge. If our community thinks everything that affects poor people does not affect us, we need to do more reading on how many of us are poor. We are disproportionately poor, particularly in trans and gender non-conforming communities and communities of color.

Second, consider this other quote from Twyla:

I wish you could be in the capital right now and see how this space that we have known our whole lives has been transformed. I was there studying at 10:30pm last night and there was art, signs, all these people, and information everywhere. The space really reflects the chant we have been using about the Capitol: 'Whose House? Our House!'

She points to the fact that the Capitol occupation is very much about reclaiming public space. As LGBTQ people, we are systematically pushed out of public space - discouraged from being ourselves at our workplaces, our kids' schools, at the grocery store, and in our local and state governments. Why do so few of us run for public office? Why are so many of our activists who do not work in LGBTQ-specific areas closeted? Because we have been sent a clear message: public space is not our space. We are not "the Public."

We are not the only community sent this message.

Immigrants are told something similar every time we open our mouths and speak a language that is not English. The systems of our towns are set up so that on every street, every bus, and every glittering downtown poor people are sent the same message: you do not belong here, this place is not for you.

This week people in Madison are saying that class warfare is real, it needs to be faced head on, and to do that we must reclaim public space. This month, people all over the Middle East are saying this, and so much more. Are we ready to recognize that this struggle (like so many struggles) is our struggle?


Recent Entries Filed under Politics:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


I was somewhere once and I heard someone say, "caitlin breedlove is the truth". i'm so glad ya'll have an article on here from her. i can't wait to read more!

Excellent post. The new world order has begun and it is nothing like the masters wanted. It is a slave revolt.

Great first post, Caitlin!

I'd also add that unions are necessary to keep employers from arbitrarily firing people and can help LGBT people get their jobs back in places where they either don't have protections or they don't want to sue.

Moreover, the bigger issue here is how the richest 1-10% of America is trying to take more and more wealth away from the lower classes. That wealthy elite does include some LGBT people who've turned their backs on the other 90+%, but it's not like they should be allowed to define the rest of the group for us (even though they have been).

Thanks for this fierce post, Caitlin! It sent shivers down my spine. I've been wondering what your queer Madisonian self has been thinking about the protests. Thank you for clearly drawing the connections between LGBTQ folks and other oppressed folks, and showing how this is a moment made possible by mass grassroots organizing, not elite "coalition" politics.

the way we've reclaimed the public space of the capitol is really incredible, caitlin! someone sent a balloon with a flyer on it that says KILL THIS BILL and it floated all the way to the top of the dome, and won't come down until the helium runs it. really cool stuff

Bill Perdue Bill Perdue | March 1, 2011 9:58 PM

Madison is labor's answer to thirty five years of remorseless attacks by Carter, Reagan, the Bushes, Clinton and Obama. It's the new Lexington and Concord, the opening shot of a revitalized workers movement willing and able to conduct mass mobilizations against the advice of bottom dwelling politicians from both right wing parties, the Democrats and Republicans, and from office dwelling union bureaucrats from DC.

It's still volatile because most unions remain in the hands of bureaucrats who've tied their personal fortunes to making deals with Democrats to insure 'labor peace'. Despite their rightwing approach bureaucrats in the AFL-CIO won't find it easy to justify accepting Walkers attack on collective bargaining. The new factor is the emergence of a large left wing in the unions calling for a general strike if Walker and the teabaggers get their way.

Walker is a typical anti-worker anti-union teabagger goon, an employee of the Koch brothers in the same way that Obama is an employee of Goldman Sachs. They both work to maintain high unemployment, enforce even more draconian cuts and drive down wages. The difference is that Walker wants to eliminate unions and Obama wants to retain them, but as company unions with broken contracts and no strike pledges. Neither is acceptable.

Unions and the workers movement are the heavy infantry of social struggles and their entry into the battles fueled by the new Depression makes it critical that GLBT communities adopt an agenda of supporting them, joining or starting unions, working to get their support and electing a new leadership to fight back.

That strategy is a thousand times more effective than all the lobbying and toadying of Democratic (sic) groups like HRC, which has accomplished nothing critical in over three decades of bootlicking.

Welcome to Bilerico as a full-fledged contributor, Caitlin! We're very lucky to have you with us!