Toshio Meronek

Life After Lock-up: Tips for Trans People

Filed By Toshio Meronek | April 27, 2011 8:30 AM | comments

Filed in: Transgender & Intersex
Tags: Grace Lawrence, Miss Major, prison, prison industrial complex, transgender

Queer prison activists like Angela Davis and Miss Major have long emphasized that trans people aretgijp-img.gif among those most severely mistreated by the prison industrial complex. Oppressive gender norms of the outside world are replicated inside prison walls, with discrimination on the outside translating into poor treatment within.

Some of these issues include sexual abuse by staff and prisoners at far higher rates than non-trans prisoners (a study from 2007 found 59% of trans people reported being sexually assaulted, compared with 4% of the overall prison population) and a higher likelihood to be separated from other prisoners in psychologically damaging solitary confinement (justified as "for their own good"). Thanks to various forms of oppression - from economic discrimination (it's more difficult for trans people to get non-illegal work) to harassment by police simply because of who they are - trans people are roped into the system at higher rates than non-trans people.

These tactics of oppression often turn cyclical under the prison industrial complex, with many gender variant people ending up back in prison soon after release. So it's important to look at ways to close the revolving door between prison and outside by opening up opportunities for employment, housing, health care and other basic human rights, and working to end policing and criminalization of certain occupations, such as sex work.

Grace Lawrence works as a counselor with the Transgender, Gender Variant, & Intersex Justice Project (TGIJP) in San Francisco, which aims to help trans people who are both in and out of prison. She shares her advice for reentering - and staying in - the outside world.

  • Before you leave prison, contact TGIJP (address below). "We have a pen pal system, where we get to know the person before they're paroled, personally, so we can know how to empower them," says Grace. TGIJP communicates with trans prisoners in any state, helping mentor them so they can be better prepared for leaving lockup. For example, a counselor might direct you on how to get your work papers, or assist with finding local organizations that can help with legal matters. (They may also be able to advocate for you while you're still inside: "We get people calling from places like Nevada or Texas, and we've contacted prison staff or the inspector general's office, just to make sure that person is being treated fairly.")
  • If you can work it out within your probation or parole terms, consider moving to a community that has more services for transgender people - a bigger city like Atlanta, Los Angeles, Minneapolis, Portland, or Seattle. While she was imprisoned in central California, Grace's lawyer was able to convince the judge on her case to transfer the case to San Francisco, where she'd found a community of trans people several years before and resources for gender variant people are more readily available.
  • If you've had a drug or alcohol issue in the past, locate a residential program that addresses these issues. "There's a lot of discrimination within the jails that can really lower a person's self-esteem" and lead to substance abuse, says Grace. She herself was a client of a program at Walden House, in San Francisco. During her year there, she received therapy and "just focused on Grace, you know?" The organization helped get her papers in order (a Social Security card, for example) which eventually led to her being able to apply for jobs.
  • Don't give up on finding legal work, if you want it. It's true, transgender people "have a harder time getting hired," says Grace. "If a non-trans person goes out for the same job, the transgender person won't get it." In fact, trans people are often unemployed at twice the rate of non-trans people. But certain employers such as Apple and Nike do include terms like "gender" and "gender identity" in their company non-discrimination policies (while also requiring that suppliers do not use prison labor), and in 2010 Goodwill opened a new San Francisco store where seven out of ten employees were trans. (Grace herself worked at Goodwill, where she used her knowledge of fashion to price clothing, and soon became a manager.) Visit the web sites of the Transgender Economic Empowerment Initiative (http://www.teeisf.org) and Transgender at Work (http://www.tgender.net/taw/) to learn more about the job search. (While seeking work, it's important to remember that corporations support and benefit from the prison industrial complex - everything from selling cement for prison walls, to using free prison labor to make their products. For example, while American Airlines has a trans-friendly hiring policy, they have used prisoners to crew their phone reservation lines.)
  • Once you're back on your feet, remember to support your community by helping others who are going through what you went through. Grace's original advisor, Miss Major, helped her get past some tough times, which caused Grace to want to give back to other trans people seeking help. Grace, who is from Liberia, where being trans is illegal, is now helping to develop a program that will aide trans people from other countries to seek asylum in the U.S. "I want to be like Miss Major when I grow up, and you can tell her that!"

Grace Lawrence lives in San Francisco, where she works with TGIJP and performs at Divas Nightclub. She is currently working on a book, The Boys Are the Most Beautiful Girls in the World.

TGI Justice Project
342 9th Street, Suite 202B
San Francisco, CA 94103
Phone: 415.252.1444

A different version of this piece will appear in the next issue of The Abolitionist.

img src


Recent Entries Filed under Transgender & Intersex:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


Just to clarify... by 'trans people' we're actually referring to trans women.

Not entirely -- the "default" is, yes, trans people, but the issues ultimately apply to both men and women.

The examples and the most common problems are often found in the Men's prisons, where the social concept of all men are rapists is lying beneath things.

But the ultimate problem is that it happens in both cases.

A significant portion of the people my org has assisted have had a history of incarceration, and that does include the guys, although the overwhelming majority of them have been women.

its one of the reasons that the prohibition on illegal activities in the orgis so strong -- despite my not having much personal issue with sex work.

I would be interested to see exact statistics of the number of incarcerated trans men in this country... I have yet to see anyone produce something like that. My problem with using 'trans people' is that it ignores the core of this issue... that it's overwhelmingly trans women who are incarcerated and who are profoundly marginalized in this society. Just as rape is a 'people' problem, to only say people get raped without mentioning that its overwhelmingly women is disingenuous.

Gender may well be an issue we ought to pay attention to - but, taking that into account, could you point us to reliable statistics showing that trans women are overwhelmingly affected?

And on those lines, I'd add that when it comes to trans folk, there's a lot here about gender identity and what is perceived as people's supposed failure to perform within such. As such, both groups - trans women and trans men - are treated violently by the prison industrial complex because of their supposed failure to conform and the economic marginalisation they find themselves in.

I don't have those statistics Yasmin, although perhaps the TGI Justice Project does. But I will say that in virtually all explorations, accounts, discussions, exposes, and news stories about trans prisoners, they're all about incarcerated trans women. The only news story about a possible trans man I've seen is an intersex ID'd person disabled person from last year who might be male-ID'ing or on the transmasculine spectrum. Yes, there may be more, just as men who are raped by women exist yet shouldn't in any way be centered in discussions of that subject. I agree that race and economics play into this and the prison industrial complex, but that doesn't mean that the very real issue of gender and how respective genders are treated even within the queer and trans communities should be ignored or made invisible.

I don't think anyone would advocate for gender being made invisible, and I don't think anyone is, but it seemed reasonable to ask for statistics since you raised the issue of numbers.

I would also caution that while, again, women, cis or trans, by and large tend to be disproportionately affected by violent systems because they are already systemically targeted by exploitation of all sorts, it's critical to remember that news reports about the brutalisation of men, cis or trans, constitute an unreliable indicator of how many such instances happen in the first place. I think we can be quite certain that violence done to most marginalised communities, of any gender identity and/or sexuality, is barely reported upon by the media. The issue of men is complicated by the cultural stereotypes of masculinity that might prevent them from reporting crimes in the first place, especially in matters like rape.

I guess my point would be: these are complicated issues and there are multiple and layered ways to approach them. Statistics are certainly one way, but not the only way.

Thanks for posting on this, Toshio.