Alex Blaze

Gay Blood Ban Eased in UK

Filed By Alex Blaze | April 11, 2011 4:00 PM | comments

Filed in: Politics
Tags: bisexual, blood, britain, donation plea, men uk, MSM

The UK is easing the gay blood ban, ever so slowly:

blood-donation.jpgThe ban on gay men donating blood is being lifted because it was decided that the rule could be discriminatory and might breach equality legislation.

However, gay men will only be permitted to donate if they have not had sexual intercourse for a decade. Homosexuals who are or have recently been sexually active will continue to be barred from giving blood.

It's slightly less ridiculous and maybe there are two or three dozen gay men that this will apply to in the UK.

The reason for the ten-year wait?

Donated blood is screened for HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases but a tiny number of infections are missed because there can be a time lag before they show themselves.

According to the British AIDS charity AVERT, the lag time on HIV tests is three weeks. So a ten-year ban after each act of gay sex is completely reasonable.

I posted last week about how sexuality can be defined based on identity, attraction, or behavior. The first two are obvious to folks in my generation while the third is a bit off; people are what they say they are but those words are meant to describe something real (even if it's something hard to see like desire), but just having sex with someone of the same sex once or in the past does not a gay or bi person make.

But there was a time when behavior was primarily used to describe someone's sexual orientation and there are still people around who believe that (see: conservatives when they talk about getting people out of the homosexual lifestyle). The Kinsey scale, for example, is based entirely on behavior, which is why so many gay people call themselves Kinsey 6's and might not get the idea of sexual fluidity as Kinsey saw it because he was talking about the sex people had, not who they were attracted to.

The gay blood ban is one of those instances where we're still defining sexuality by behavior. LGBT people quite willingly call it a ban on gay and bi men giving blood, but that's not the question that the Red Cross asks; the goal of the ban is to keep all men who have had sex with men since 1977, regardless of attraction or identity.

The UK, though, will just ban men who've had sex with men since 2001. Neither Spain nor Italy ban blood from men who have had sex with men, for any time period, and instead determine risk based on promiscuity and sex practices. Several other countries have a one to five year waiting period. I haven't heard of any incidents of someone getting HIV through a blood transfusion recently in those countries.

img flickr


Recent Entries Filed under Politics:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


Aint been laid in a decade? Buck up! You can give blood!!

*sighs*

I know most coleages at work are shocked when I tell them I'd love to give blood, but the Red Cross won't accept it. I explain the current policy to them, and they insist I'm wrong. Then we go (usually together, once a year...) to the person collecting blood and ask, and of course they confirm it. I us it as an educational opportunity.

Another tactic I've used is to point out that they are happy to accept your blood if you've had sexy with tons of strangers in the past few months, just as long as you're not a man OR those strangers were women. I also point out that since many people in my office are under 35, if any of them were sexually abused as children, or "experimented" ever, this also applies to them since the ban is from 1977 on. The Red Cross people don't like me much for that one, but it's still quite true.

Funny part: Until I lost my virginity, I was highly sought after, being a regular O- donor. I have several old red blood drop pins and a nice 20-gallon hat pin from back then. I'd love to be able to donate again, but don't see the point if they're not going to accept or use my blood.