Don Davis

My Last Weekend: A Health Care in America Story

Filed By Don Davis | July 24, 2011 3:00 PM | comments

Filed in: Politics
Tags: Barack Obama, Democrats, economic policy, health care reform, Medicaid, Medicare, Obamacare, politics, reform, Republicans

Thumbnail image for Prescription drugsSo I disappeared for a full week, right in the middle of what should have been a busy writing schedule, and I have to claim some "personal days" to cover the time we missed here at the blog - but it won't be time entirely wasted. Instead, I'm going to jump into my own personal life for today's story, and I'm going to do it so that we can stimulate some thinking about where we really need to go to if we ever hope to make some sense out of the crazy way we deliver health care in this country. Since this appears to be the weekend that a lot of decisions are either going to be made about the future of our "social safety net"...or they wont; we're entirely unsure...let's talk about how it actually works for a lot of us - and how it could work a lot better.
But the worst part of the Industrial Revolution - and the part that has never been documented - is what happened to the role of managers. The owners of factories realized they needed a layer of insulation between themselves and the people they were exploiting. They needed the type of people who were incapable of understanding the workers' pleas for common sense, decency, and safe working conditions. The owners wisely chose managers for these roles. --Scott Adams, from the book "Dogbert's Top Secret Management Handbook"
So as most of you know, I am a blogger, and that means, for better or worse, that this is how I'm trying to make a living - and as a result I, along with about 50,000,000 other Americans, find myself on the DGS Health Plan (never heard of DGS? It's the "Don't Get Sick" health plan). So what do I do? The same as a lot of you: I don't get sick. And up 'til now, it's worked out surprisingly well, even though I weigh more than I should and I have a coke addiction that can see me consuming as much as 2 liters in a single day...but by last Friday I had one of those tooth twinges building up that you know is not going to end up well. By Friday night things were getting bad enough that I had to tell The Girlfriend that we were very likely to be going to an emergency room, if not that night, certainly by morning - unless things cleared up on their own, which, if you're an optimist, could happen. So much for optimism. Midday Saturday we're in downtown Seattle and I'm waiting in line to be seen by an intake clerk, then a triage nurse, and then a financial counselor, because there's no way I can really take on a big medical bill. I'm lucky that Washington State has a "Charity Care Law"; that law requires Washington's hospitals to accept all comers at the emergency room, regardless of ability to pay - and there's been a considerable increase in demand over the past four years. (The Department of Health reports that $591 million in such care was provided in '07, and in the last year for which numbers are available, '09, the same cost had run up to $846 million; that's a 43% jump in just two years. The odds are pretty good that the '10 and '11 numbers will also show an increase that's well above the rate of inflation.) Anyway, after that they showed me to a sort of mini-emergency room facility, I was examined by a medical student and his instructor, and they decided that maybe a CAT scan would be a good idea, just to determine exactly how badly and how widespread this infection might be. I rode the ride, an assessment was made, and it time to offer up my various elbows to my medical student, which left me with a couple of bruises that are still healing, and him with a couple of experience points. More assessment followed the return of the lab results; as a result I was given a prescription of a rather unpleasant antibiotic that I'll be taking for a few more days, but all in all, for me, things worked out pretty well. That said...imagine if I lived in Canada. First thing, I waited longer than I should have with this infection, and if I had a general practitioner with whom I had an ongoing relationship, I would have gone there at least a day sooner. That delay imposed a few costs: I had that CAT scan, took up ER time and a mini-ER suite; instead I could have made an office visit, and probably walked out with a prescription for the same antibiotic with a quick exam or just a blood test. There is no financial counselor in Canadian healthcare - instead, you present your Provincial insurance card, and that's that. For those not aware, Canadian healthcare, for the most part, works like American care, except there's only one insurance company, and that's each Province; they also collect taxes to fund the services. That means providers only deal with one insurer, and all of that cuts a lot of administrative expenses out of the system. It also means patients never have to worry about whether their provider will be "in the network". (**Fun Fact:** bankruptcy is now a big part of the American medical system. In 1981 8% of bankruptcies were related to medical costs, but by 2007 that number appears to have grown to 62%, all this according to the *Journal of the American Medical Association*. Three-quarters of that 62% had medical insurance. Canada does not have a medical bankruptcy problem of statistical significance.) When you add all this together, it begins to explain how it's possible that Canada can insure all their people for about 11% of their 2009 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) when we pay about 17% of GDP and still leave a huge portion of the population either completely uninsured or unable to pay for care even if they have insurance, due to what won't be covered when the bill comes in at the end of the month. (**Fun Fact #2: **Sweden, Switzerland, France, Germany, Iceland - in fact, any country that you can name on the face of the Earth - pays less than we do for their health care. By a lot. When it comes to the cost of health care, the USA is #1.) So it's not all skittles and beer, up there in Canada. You might have to wait a while to get some types of care, and it appears that there's an element of "rationing by waiting period", which is a constant source of complaints up there. (The counterargument is that rationing of some sort is required in any medical insurance scheme; otherwise, you'll have folks at the doctor's for no reason at all, and that'll quickly drive a system broke.) There are co-pays, for some services, and no coverage for others, depending on your Province, (nonemergency dental and vision are often not covered) and that can lead to some out-of-pocket, but for the most part taxes cover the bills. And just as we in the USA are struggling to pay for medical care, so is everyone else: controlling medical costs are hard, for a variety of reasons, including the cost of paying medical professionals to do work in a dangerous environment that can often be hard to automate. Dangerous, you say?
In healthcare, back injuries, frequently caused by overexertion, occur at a very high rate. Healthcare industry workers sustain 4.5 times more overexertion injuries than any other type of worker...According to national statistics, six of the top 10 professions at greatest risk for back injury are: nurse's aides, licensed practical nurses, registered nurses, health aides, radiology technicians, and physical therapists.
So the other reason I'm having this conversation today is because I was having a talk with a very nice gentleman just about 48 hours ago who is a bit more conservative politically than I, and he wondered how I felt about "Obamacare" (formally known as the Affordable Health Care Act). I'm not a big fan of that plan, I'm not, and that's because I'd much rather do something like expand Medicare to everyone, or "go all Canada"; either choice seems simpler and easier and doable at far lower administrative costs than any plan that relies on private insurers, as the Affordable Health Care Act does. So there you go: that's how I spent the weekend, and a couple of days after to boot, and if we were living in Canada I could have had the same problem, but it would have cost the healthcare system a whole lot less money - and when everyone gathered at the White House today, I wish that's what they had been talking about.

Recent Entries Filed under Politics:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.


Jay Kallio | July 26, 2011 5:14 AM

Definitely, the Canadian single payer publicly administered health insurance is by far the least expensive, most efficient, and above all, most humane and egalitarian health care program in the world. It's my first choice of health care programs of all. If anyone wishes to see in detail how awesome a single payer program is go check out the website of Physicians for a National Health Program, or Health Care Now!, or the California Nurse's Association, where we have terrific information available.

The Obama health "reform" act, PPACA, does little other than ever more firmly empower and entrench the private health insurance industry in the fabric of our health care delivery system. They will gain a huge number of additional customers for their ridiculously overpriced and undervalue insurance products that do not cover the services people need, and everyone will be forced to buy their policies. With the massive new revenue stream they receive from every American being forced to obtain insurance they will do what they have always done - buy even more politicians and get them ever more firmly under their control, so the US will never be able to either regulate them so they act in the public interest, or enforce the puny regulations that are enacted now, or ever scale back the tremendous power they already have over our very lives.

That's what profiteering corporations do with money - buy the laws they like and make even more money. In this case, over our dead bodies. Literally.

The greatest unseen benefit of the Canadian system is the comfort of knowing that one will be looked after in the event of illness. As a pre-op TS, I can look forward to SRS in January without saving financial ruin. I also received the necessary counselling and psychiatrist care during transition in a timely manner with the additional emotional burden of finding the means to pay. (In transitioning, I had to leave my job for personal emotional reasons.)

Jay Kallio | July 26, 2011 5:54 PM

Thanks for weighing in, Ann! Canada is way ahead of the rest of the world on health care, it should be a shining model for the rest of us. I'm so glad you have received the care you need. We do not, here in the US, even many paying for the most comprehensive health insurance available do not receive what we need, and have additional out of pocket expenses that bankrupt us, and send us into poverty.

There is tremendous comfort in knowing one will have access to health care when facing a catastrophic illness or injury, so you and your loved ones won't also be reduced to destitution, and helpless despair, as so many end up here in the US. It is truly barbaric here, how we let each other be destroyed, live in degradation and shame and terror, when ill or injured. As an emergency medical worker all my life, I have seen so many people destroyed, through no fault of their own, and denied care when they needed it most.

Gaytorguy | July 30, 2011 1:01 PM

People seem to blame Medicare as a wasteful enterprise. But consider this fact. Even with some waste, and fraud; Medicare's medical expenditures rose 4.7% last year. Private insurers rose 7.6%. And the private insurers are supposed to be the waste and fraud watchers!
Medicare for all is better than any other solution!

Bill Perdue Bill Perdue | July 30, 2011 2:25 PM

Constitutional guarantees for socialized medicine, good housing, maternity leave for both parents, long vacations, and wages and benefits for all workers, retirees, students and child caregivers at high union levels are the way to go.