Mattilda Bernstein Sycamore

Another Independent Press Catastrophe -- The End of Punk Planet

Filed By Mattilda Bernstein Sycamore | June 19, 2007 4:21 PM | comments

Filed in: Entertainment, Media
Tags: Independent press, Independent Press Association, punk, Punk Planet

I've always had mixed feelings about Punk Planet -- and punk, really. Punk was what I wanted to be in high school but I was too much of a faggot to ever get accepted among the purposefully downtrodden. I still loved Fugazi shows and imagined myself on double-decker buses romancing with The Clash (I was stuck in DC at the end of the '80s/early '90s), but grew to prefer the take-me-to-the-sky antics of danceclub delirium, and as my aesthetics became an increasingly strange hybrid of high-contrast thriftstore extravagance, I honed my politics into an enraged queer defiant dissonance -- the funny thing is that once I transcended punk I became punk (to certain people, anyway -- although I'd fled to the West Coast), I guess that's the point or something although I've never tried to claim the word, I'm afraid of such dangerous nostalgia. Eventually I finally figured out what thuggish (but far from punkish) guys on the street meant when they'd come up to me and say are you punk? In all my carefully-coiffed day-glo naïveté, I didn't realize they were using punk to mean faggot, well bring it!

But back to Punk Planet, I probably would've loved it in high school because it embodied so many of my contradictions at that point (without admitting them, which I never would have done at that point either) -- a calculated sense of style that was really more design than diy, a certain type of consumer fetish gimmicky resistance mentality. But Punk Planet didn't arrive until I was several years out of high school, by that time I'd moved past certain offerings.

But Punk Planet also developed some amazing journalism -- I remember an issue way back that was about the death penalty, and how excited it made me to see that focus -- sure, alongside pages and pages of whiteboy bubblepunk bands bouncing slit-your-wrists straightness. But I'm getting distracted -- the point is that Punk Planet also ran some great, in-depth political articles (my issues are still in boxes from moving months ago, so I can't list the articles right now, although I loved the "Revenge of Print" issues which included analysis of independent press consolidation). The magazine also became more stunningly laid-out, impeccably organized and lavishly designed -- perhaps this is confusing, what I mean is that it got gorgeous. Still, there were some of the same tired straightboy rants and endless pages of boring band reviews, but also some inspiring mayhem. But don't get me started on that Miranda July cover story not long ago, after Miranda July had become the toast of Hollywood, declaring that, even after a Prada fashion spread in Interview, she was still "underground."

Truth be told, I have deep critiques of almost every publication, including the ones that make up the independent press that I love - I'll admit that I thought Punk Planet was invulnerable, a glimmering success story even as so many independent publications went down the tubes. Even with recent media consolidation scandals, I thought Punk Planet would labor on, and when I opened my email today to find that this would not, in fact, be the case, I was stunned, mouth hanging open -- I even cried a little bit, truth be told -- I do think the world of independent publications becomes weaker without Punk Planet, this world that does actually mean a lot to me.

I think this part of Punk Planet's statement is the most striking, because it ties it in with so many of the other publication struggles:

... We must acknowledge that the financial hit we took in October of 2005, when our newsstand distributor announced that it was in dire straits, was worse than we originally thought. As the dust began to clear from their January bankruptcy announcement, we began to realize that the magazine was left in significantly worse shape, distribution-wise, than they let on.

Add to that the stagnation that the independent record world is suffering
under and the effect that has had on our ad sales, not to mention the loss of
independent bookstores with a vested interest in selling our publication, and it
all adds up to a desperate situation. This has been made far worse by the
exhaustion felt from a year and a half of fighting our own distributor. It was a
situation that didn't have an exit strategy other then, well, exiting.

In other words, another casualty of independent press consolidation, and especially the failures/corruptions of the Independent Press Association. What is next?

Most recently, Mattilda edited Nobody Passes: Rejecting the Rules of Gender and Conformity. She blogs at

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

Man! And they kept an awesome blog that I linked to several times here. I wonder how much the stagnation of independent media has to do with the proliferation of online magazines and blogs that provide people with free reading material.

Completely unrelatedly but not really, Planetout, Inc., has been having financial troubles lately, and they own Out, the Advocate, and a few other publications. But that one I know has a lot to do with the internet, since the only time I picked up the Advocate at a friend's house I noticed that I had already read all the articles in it several weeks before. It really made it seem worthless.

Actually, I think the PlanetOut troubles have to do with the fact that they bought the gay cruise line, whatever that's called, and that's a sinking ship -- at least from what I've read...

Thanks for writing!