Jessica Hoffmann

Obama: Live from the HRC Candidates' Forum

Filed By Jessica Hoffmann | August 09, 2007 9:03 PM | comments

Filed in: Marriage Equality, Politics
Tags: Barack Obama, election 2008, gay rights, HRC, Logo

[EDITOR'S NOTE:] Transcript of Senator Obama's section after the jump.


I'm thinking I respect that he's talking about all this within the boundaries that we might care about his thoughts on it -- he might be in a position to do something regarding legislation, legal rights, and so all his answers come back to that -- ensuring equal rights, focusing on the role of government in that. I think I like that better than any of these folks speaking beyond that -- because their work won't really be beyond that ...

[6:08] So, yeah, courtesy of HRC Pres Joe Solmonese, the first question was about marriage: What place does the church have in government-sanctioned civil marriages.

Obama wants to disentangle the word "marriage" from the civil rights that are given to couples -- but then, of course, why this frame? Why are these rights given to couples, particularly, exclusively? (Not expecting to hear this conversation on TV, which is why I'm sayin'.) And then Solmonese calls civil marriage "like separate but equal." Thoughts?


MS. CARLSON: For the next two hours, the Democratic candidates running for president will be here to talk directly to you, live and commercial-free, only on LOGO. You'll find a wealth of information about the candidates and their positions on the issues at and at the, where this show is also being streamed live.

Finally, before we begin, a word about the order of appearance at tonight's event. The candidates, who will appear one after another, picked their time slots in the order of their confirmation to attend the forum.

And now, with that, it is my pleasure to introduce our first candidate. Barack Obama was elected to the U.S. Senate from Illinois in 2004. The senator previously served eight years in the state senate in Illinois. Please welcome Senator Barack Obama. (Cheers, applause.)

SEN. OBAMA: Thank you. Thank you.

MS. CARLSON: Well, welcome, Senator. You are a rock star, I see. (Chuckles.)

SEN. OBAMA: Well, I don't know about that.

MS. CARLSON: Yeah, I've seen it. It's not quite as hot here as it was in Chicago the other night --

SEN. OBAMA: (Chuckles.)

MS. CARLSON: -- literally and figuratively, perhaps.

SEN. OBAMA: Absolutely.

MS. CARLSON: We'll see.

SEN. OBAMA: Well, it's wonderful to be here. I want to thank, first of all, HRC and LOGO for setting this up. I think it is an historic moment, not just for the LGBT community but for America. And so I'm glad that I'm participating and glad I kind of got the ball rolling.

MS. CARLSON: Yeah. Start-off batter here.

SEN. OBAMA: Absolutely.

MS. CARLSON: Welcome.

SEN. OBAMA: Thank you. Thank you. (Applause.)

MS. CARLSON: I'm going to have some questions for you, but first I'm going to turn it over to Joe.

MR. SOLMONESE: Senator, thank you so much for joining us. It's
a real honor to have you here with us tonight. And thank you for
being the first to accept our invitation.

You have said in previous debates that it is up to individual
religious denominations to decide whether or not to recognize same-sex
marriage. And so my question is, what place does the church have in
government-sanctioned civil marriages?

SEN. OBAMA: Well, it is my strong belief that the government has
to treat all citizens equally. I come from that in part out of
personal experience. When you're a black guy named Barack Obama, you
know what it's like to be on the outside. And so my concern is
continually to make sure that the rights that are conferred by the
state are equal for all people. That's why I opposed NOMA in 2006
when I ran for the United States Senate. (Applause.) That's why --
that's why I am a strong supporter not of a weak version of civil
unions, but of a strong version, in which the rights that are
conferred at the federal level to persons of -- you know, who are part
of the same sex union are compatible.
Now, as a consequence, I don't think that the church should be
making these determinations when it comes to legal rights conferred by
the state. I do think that individual denominations have the right to
make their own decisions as to whether they recognize same sex
couples. My denomination, United Church of Christ, does. Other
denominations may make a decision, and obviously, part of keeping a
separation of churches and state is also to make sure that churches
have the right to exercise their freedom of religion.

But when it comes to federal rights, the over 1,100 rights that
right now are not being given to same sex couples, I think that's
unacceptable, and as president of the United States, I am going to
fight hard to make sure that those rights are available.

MR. SOLOMONESE: So -- (interrupted by applause). So to follow
up on your point about the state issue, if you were back in the
Illinois legislature where you served and the issue of civil marriage
came before you, how would you have voted on that?

SEN. OBAMA: Well, I -- you know, my view is that we should try
to disentangle what has historically been the issue of the word
"marriage," which has religious connotations to some people, from the
civil rights that are given to couples, in terms of hospital
visitation, in terms of whether or not they can transfer property or
any of the other -- Social Security benefits and so forth. So it
depends on how the bill would've come up.

I would've supported and would continue to support a civil union
that provides all the benefits that are available for a legally
sanctioned marriage. And it is then, as I said, up to religious
denominations to make a determination as to whether they want to
recognize that as marriage or not.

MR. SOLMONESE: But on the grounds of civil marriage, can you see
to our community where it -- that comes across as sounding like
separate but equal?

SEN. OBAMA: Well, look, you know, when my parents got married in
1960, '61, you know, it would have been illegal for them to be married
in a number of states in the South.
So obviously, this is something that I understand intimately, it's
something that I care about.

But I would also say this, that if I were advising the civil
rights movement back in 1961 about its approach to civil rights, I
would have probably said it's less important that we focus on an anti-
miscegenation law than we focus on a voting rights law and a non-
discrimination and employment law and all the legal rights that are
conferred by the state.

Now, it's not for me to suggest that you shouldn't be troubled by
these issues. I understand that and I'm sympathetic to it. But my
job as president is going to be to make sure that the legal rights
that have consequences on a day to day basis for loving same sex
couples all across the country, that those rights are recognized and
enforced by my White House and by my Justice Department.

MS. CARLSON: You know, before I got to Melissa with her
question, I've been working with the Logo people for a couple of days
so I have more of a feeling for what troubles them.
And it seems like you've -- religion owns the word marriage, or you're
letting religion have marriage and then civilly you get civil unions.
But you got to get married, and I got to get married, but Joe doesn't
get to be married. And that really does mean that it's a lesser
thing. It looks like a politically feasible thing to do, but --

SEN. OBAMA: Well, you know, as I've proposed it, it wouldn't be
a lesser thing, from my perspective. And look, you know, semantics
may be important to some. From my perspective, what I'm interested is
making sure that those legal rights are available to people.

And if we have a situation in which civil unions are fully
enforced, are widely recognized, people have civil rights under then
law, then my sense is that's enormous progress. And that is the kind
of progress that I think HRC would be proud of and I would be proud of
as president. And that's what I'm going to try to lead.

MS. CARLSON: Okay, thank you.


MS. ETHERIDGE: Thank you very much.
First, I just want to say how incredibly humbled and honored I am
to be here. I am not a professional politician. I'm not even a
journalist. I'm an incredibly privileged rock star -- (laughter,
applause) -- and I'm --

SEN. OBAMA: That's a good enough reason.

MS. ETHERIDGE: I'm very, very grateful and honored here to
represent my community and be able to speak for so many people who
need to have their government's help.

And with that, thank you. I want to say hello. It's a pleasure
to meet you, Senator Obama.

SEN. OBAMA: It's great to meet you.

MS. ETHERIDGE: And you -- you have this reputation -- and not
only in my heart and my experience of you -- of being an incredible
orator. You speak, you touch many of us, and you have. And we have
lots of hope.

And I see you speaking to a very divided America. We have been
-- the last eight years we have been subject to a great fear that has
divided us all between races, between economic classes, and of course
gays and lesbians often feel like we are at the very end of that, the
"us and them" role.

SEN. OBAMA: Right.

MS. ETHERIDGE: If you're elected president, what are you going
to do? What are you going to do to bring this country back together?

SEN. OBAMA: Well, it's a great question. Part of the reason
that LGBT issues are important to me is because I got into politics in
part because I don't like people looking down on other people.
It bothers me. Maybe it's something that my mother instilled in me.
Maybe it's the experience of being an African-American and at times
being discriminated against. So, the cause that all of you are
involved with is part of what prompted me to get into politics.

But part of what prompts me is also this hopefulness, this belief
that, you know, there's a core decency to most people, and certainly
most Americans, and that our founding documents, I think, have a set
of universal truths that are really important. And the key question
for the next president is can we tap back into that core decency and
can we appeal to what Lincoln called the better angels of our nature.

And part of that involves, I think, when it comes to LGBT issues,
acknowledging the reality that people experience every day. That's
why when I was at the Democratic Convention in 2004, I said there are
no red states, there are now blue states, but I also said, you know,
we've got gay friends in the red states and we've got -- you know, we
play Little League in the blue states.
Trying to acknowledge that people's experience on a day-to-day basis
is they've got gay friends, they've got gay family members that --
they love them and they cherish them, and somehow our politics creates
craziness and fear that doesn't match up with people's day-to-day
experience. And it's the job of the president, I think, to talk about
these issues in ways that encourage people to recognize themselves in
each other, and when I talk like this, by the way, you know, sometimes
the Washington press corps rolls its eyes and says, "Ugh! It's so

MS. CARLSON: No eye rolling here yet. (Light laughter.)

SEN. OBAMA: Not yet --

MS. : No, no, no.

SEN. OBAMA: But -- but people do because the sense is, you know,
"Obama, he's always talking about hope." It's -- you know, I'm a hope
monger -- (laughter) -- but I believe that and -- (interrupted by

MS. ETHERIDGE: I grew up in the Midwest. I grew up believing if
you work hard and you're good, then you'll succeed and you can be a
good citizen.

SEN. OBAMA: Right.

MS. ETHERIDGE: I grew up believing in our country, in this great
America. This is the greatest country. And I grew up believing in
those documents, and those documents say equality to everyone --

SEN. OBAMA: Absolutely.

MS. ETHERIDGE: -- given by our Creator. And my Creator made me
what I am --

SEN. OBAMA: Right.

MS. ETHERIDGE: -- and I believe that. (Applause.)

And as you lead, don't be afraid. Don't let that fear -- be the
first one to make the change, to bring it.

All right, thank you.

MS. CARLSON: Thanks, Melissa. (Applause.)
MR. CAPEHART: Senator Obama, you've gotten some praise for

taking to the pulpits of black churches and telling the black

community, talking to the black community, about its responsibilities.

Now you and I both know that there's a homophobia problem in the black


SEN. OBAMA: Right.

MR. CAPEHART: So how are you going to talk to the black

community about that, both as candidate and if you are elected to the

White House as president?

SEN. OBAMA: You know, I have already done so. I mean, some of

you saw at the Howard debate, a -- Tavis Smiley had organized, I

specifically raised the homophobia in our community as an impediment

to dealing with AIDS issues. You know, I'm somebody who talks about

LGBT issues not just before HRC.

I was with Harold Ford. He organized a forum of black ministers

in Tennessee . And I specifically talked about the degree to which the

notion of gay marriage in black churches has been used to divide, has

been used to distract. I specifically pointed out that if there's any

pastor here who can point out a marriage that has been broken up as a

consequence of seeing two men or two women holding hands, then we --

you should tell me, because I haven't seen any evidence of it. And --


And what I've also said -- and what I've also said is, if you

think that issue is more important to the black family, which is under

siege -- if you think that's more important than the fact that black

men don't have any jobs and are struggling in the inner cities, then I

profoundly disagree with you. So this goes to the earlier point that

we were talking about, Melissa. I think when there's truth-telling

involved, people respond, as long as you don't come at people in a

heavy-handed way but rather you approach them based on their own

experience and their own truth.

And the black community, I think, has a diversity of opinion, as

you and I both know. There are people who recognize that if we're

going to talk about justice and civil rights and fairness, that should

apply to all people, not just some. And there are some folks who,

coming out of the church, have, you know, elevated one line in Romans

above the Sermon in the Mount.

And so my job as a leader, not just of African-Americans but hopefully

as a leader of Americans, is to tell the truth, which is this has been

a political football that's been used. It is unfortunate. It's got

to stop. And when it stops, we will then be able to address the

legitimate and serious concerns that face the black family.

MR. SOLMONESE: Senator, real quickly, a recent poll of The New

York Times and MTV of Americans ages 17 to 20 show that 44 percent of

them favor same-sex marriage compared to 28 percent of the public.

Now, you're running as a candidate of change. But how can you run as

a candidate of change when your stance on same-sex marriage is

decidedly old school?

SEN. OBAMA: Oh, come on, now. (Laughter.) I mean, look, guys,

you know, I mean, we can have this conversation for the duration of

the 15 minutes. But there's a reason why I was here first. It's

because I've got a track record of working on these issues.

If people are interested at the federal level, they can look at

who was the chief co-sponsor of Illinois ' version of ENDA, which we

passed. If people are interested in my stance on these issues, I've

got a track record of working with the LGBT community.

What I have focused on and what I will continue to focus on is

making sure that the rights that are provided by the federal

government and the state governments and local governments are ones

that are provided to everybody. And that's a standard that I think

can meet, and I don't make promises I can't keep. And on this issue,

I have been at the forefront of any of the presidential candidates.

MS. CARLSON: Senator, I want to do a viewer-generated question.

I want to do a Margaret-generated question very quickly.

SEN. OBAMA: Go ahead.

MS. CARLSON: Would you put the fight among gays and lesbians for

civil rights on a par with the civil rights movement for African-


SEN. OBAMA: Well, you know, my attitude is if people are being

treated unfairly and unequally, then they're being treated unfairly

and unequally and it needs to be fixed. So I'm always very cautious

about getting into comparisons of victimology. You know, the issues

that gays and lesbians face today are different from the issues that

were faced by African-Americans under Jim Crow.

That doesn't mean, though, that there aren't parallels in the sense

that legal status is not equal. And that has to be fixed. But -- but

I think it's important not to -- not to look at the black candidate

and wonder, you know, whether or not he's going to be more sympathetic

or less sympathetic to these issues. I'm going to be more sympathetic

not because I'm black. I'm going to be more sympathetic because this

has been the cause of my life and will continue to be the cause of my

life, making sure that everybody's treated fairly and that we've got

an expansive view of America , where everybody's invited in and we are

all working together to create the kind of America that we want for

the next generation. (Applause.)

MS. CARLSON: I had great viewer-generated question here for you.

You're never going to know what it is.

But now you get to sum up for 30 seconds or a minute.

SEN. OBAMA: Well, listen. It's a pleasure. This went too

quick. I want more time -- (laughter) -- but I don't have it.

MS. CARLSON: We'd like to give it to you.

SEN. OBAMA: But -- but the only thing I want to say is this.

All the candidates in this race are going to be terrific on these

issues compared to, certainly, the candidates in the other party right

now. And that's unfortunate because this shouldn't be a partisan


The one thing I guess I would say about my candidacy, and

something you should think about, is I don't just talk about these

issues where it's convenient.

I mean, there's a reason that I spoke about the importance of gay and

lesbian issues in a -- the most important speech of my life. I didn't

have to. There's a reason why, in my announcement, I talked about

these issues. There's a reason why I talk about gays and lesbians and

transgender people in my stump speeches. I'm somebody who I think is

willing to talk about these issues, even when it's hard, in front of

black ministers. I'm willing to talk about AIDS at Saddleback Church

to evangelicals and talk about why we need to have condom distribution

to deal with the scourge of AIDS.

So that's the kind of political courage that I hope all of you

recognize is going to be necessary in order for us to create the kind

of America that we all want.

And I appreciate your time. (Applause.) Thank you.

MS. CARLSON: And we're happy you came here.

SEN. OBAMA: I had a great time. (Applause continues at length.)

MS. CARLSON: Nice to see you.

SEN. OBAMA: Thank you. Thanks. Thank you so much. Thank you

so much. Thank you. Thank you.

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

He did alright. He looked rather nervous though - or is that just me? He said, "uh" so many times...

My opinion of Obama actually slightly improved. I know how most of these candidates stand on the issues that are going to be discussed tonight, so my bar is set on the question of who knows the issues best. Who can break out and speak with breadth and depth on LGBT issues. I think Obama has done a good job of beating my expectations for him.

All for now...

Leland Frances | August 9, 2007 10:29 PM

Helloooooooo. Danger, Will Robinson. Selective perception at work. Some positive comments, but boil down all that he said and it still comes out as SEPARATE but equal. The logical extension of which is that he would support segregated schools: white children here, Black children there. Is that acceptable?

And, Christ of the Andes, the man must have balls the size of basketballs. He stood there and didn't just functionally define straights and gays as two different classes of people but went back 40 years and told his own people that they shouldn't have been concerned about laws banning and PUNISHING mixed marriages. I don't know if the Lovings of Loving v. Virginia are still alive, but I would luv to see him stand in front of them and say to their face, "You were wrong to object to having to move out of Virginia or go to jail solely because she is Black and you are white. You were wrong to object to, by judge's order, not even being able to visit family and friends in Virginia, set foot in the state, for the next 25 years or go to jail."


Leland, it's obvious that Obama is being pragmatic and focusing on what is achievable.

I think it's great that Obama brough up AIDS/HIV prevention w/o even being asked... I know that's his issue but still.

I'm thinking that his answer to Carlson's question about comparing oppression actually removed the bad taste in my mouth that the question itself generated. I think I'll post on that tomorrow, but tonight it's all about Jessica!

Leland Frances | August 9, 2007 11:04 PM

"it's obvious that Obama is being pragmatic and focusing on what is achievable" Then let him just say that—which I AGREE with, at least for 2007/8. But he's not. He's saying he BELIEVES we ARE a separate class of people somehow and some words "belong" to only the class to which he belongs in terms of orientation. I was hoping but not counting on his having grown from his old rhetoric about this. "Equal" is "equal" except when it comes out of his mouth. And they mocked Bill for saying, "It depends on what 'is' is."

What I didn't expect was him to insult his OWN people's historical struggles. Is anyone aware that there is, in fact, evidence that efforts to overturn miscegenation laws slowed down the advancement of other Black civil rights?

I'll vote for him if he gets the nomination but, damn, the man doesn't even understand his own people's struggles so it's going to continue to be a steep learning curve for him about marriage equality.

Leland Frances | August 9, 2007 11:08 PM

Hmmm. Looks like some of the transcript is yet to be posted. Perhaps he acquits himself with other statements I've yet to see. If so, I apologize for my misperceptions based on what I've seen so far.

Oh, the church -- I love the church, what a good question... I'll have to think about that one...