Sara Whitman

Homo Sent Home for the Holidays

Filed By Sara Whitman | December 18, 2007 8:53 PM | comments

Filed in: Media
Tags: Family Circle, Ladies Home Journal, lesbian, LGBT families, Meredith Corp, moms,, single mother

What a surprise. After a quick six-month stint, the only lesbian blogger at has been cancelled.

Merry Christmas from the Meredith Corporation, as they officially gave Harlyn Aizley, the sole lesbian mom blogging for their new site, the pink slip.

It seems Ms. Aizley, the author of “Buying Dad” and the editor of “Confessions of the Other Mother” did not get enough “hits” on her blog to continue being a valued member of the payroll.

I’m not a fan of Meredith Corporation’s corral of magazines. Parents, Baby, Ladies Home Journal, Family Circle are all rags that tend to make middle class white women feel good about themselves as decorators, housewives and mommies. Sure, I’m white and I’m a mom but nothing said in those magazines even remotely speak to me.

Until Aizley started posting. Then I started reading. Her blog, Are You My Mothers? made me willing to fill out all the forms to read her work on a regular basis. Finally, mainstream press found my lifestyle and decided to celebrate it.


“Each of our brands attracts an enthusiastic audience based on life stage, lifestyle and affinity.” Meredith proudly proclaims, under a banner of images of women, their body parts and plenty of smiles. Unless you are a lesbian. No room for our lifestyle, life stages, or affinity.

The top bloggers at, in October, received about 11,000 unique hits per month while writing about their lives as parents. Straight, mostly white, parents. Aizley, a lesbian, single, and raising her daughter received 6,000 unique hits a month. She had plenty of straight women reading her blog not because they were cruising to find a lesbian experience but because Aizley is a good writer.

I don’t want to get too picky but… let’s look at the numbers. Aizley got more than 50% of the traffic of the straight writers that means she outperforming the demographics 10x. And how many are queer parents are out there? 5 million lesbian/gay parents raising 9-10 million children and spending $22 billion on them?

Ah, but that’s the businesswoman in me speaking. All those silly little numbers make me wonder who is running the place and if they need to borrow my calculator.

Aizley expresses the world in which she’s navigating with her five year old daughter with humor, honesty and an edge only a lesbian mom can give- the reality of what it is to be just outside of the mainstream, trying to be a good parent, and maintaining her dignity. What it feels like when a play date request is denied- all the normal stuff moms go through and then added fear- is it because I’m gay?

I’ve had a lot of straight suburban moms over the years, who have wanted to be friends, who wanted to be hip, and cool, and come over with their kids for play dates. Nervously, the initial conversations always involved a proud proclamation their near brushes with lesbianism.

I once had a roommate who had a friend who was a lesbian. Really.

To which I would smile, nod and try not to let my eyes roll. They were proud of themselves for being so progressive, and open to the idea that two moms were raising kids in their neighborhood.

Some would even start to flirt, as if I were the ultimate safety net- another woman who kind of looked like a man but wasn’t really one.

They would ask questions about how we got pregnant, was it really true about turkey basters? They were tickled by the idea you could shop for the kind of sperm you wanted- no being stuck with your husband’s family history of manic depression. They were honestly curious.

It created bridges. I knew the next time they met a two-mom family? They would get past some of the silly questions and get to know them. It made life for my kids easier. It made their kids more accepting not only of gay families, but any structure that was different from their own.

Aizley’s blog was doing that, online, every day, across the country. The people who wrote in and pleaded for to keep her? Mostly straight women.

It is not Meredith Corporation’s job to be progressive. It’s not their job to do anything but sell magazines. They proclaim: “In distinct editorial voices, they address the core categories of home, family and personal development. Across the spectrum, we support and inspire the reader, serving her needs and celebrating her joys.”

Just not lesbian inspiration, needs or joys.

Aizley will be finished at the end of the month. I know she will be posting at’s blog, a LGBT family resource site. “It’s like moving back to my small hometown in the mid-west after fun and games in the big city,” she said. “Thank goodness for our people.”

Yes, I agree. I am thankful.

But it should not be a choice between preaching to the choir and having the richness of new and different experiences to read about, learn from, acknowledge.

Meredith Corporation took a bold step when they invited Aizley to blog, including a lesbian mom in the spectrum.

Shame on them for canceling her.

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

Perhaps they should consider the design of the site too. It was always hard to actually find her blog and once I did there wasn't an RSS feed that I could find so I didn't have to search all over the darn site to find her.

I'm glad she's found a blog home. The folks from Family Equality are good people.

She was getting paid to get 6K unique views a month? Wow. We're getting a lot more hits here at TBP and almost no money.

Where do I sign up to become a pro-blogger at one of these mags?

But yeah, they so should have kept her.