Amy Hunter

Yelling at the TV

Filed By Amy Hunter | November 18, 2010 3:00 PM | comments

Filed in: Marriage Equality, Politics
Tags: Concerned Women for America, GOProud, Jimmy LaSalvia, Tea Party, Wendy Wright

I have to be careful when I watch cable news. If I'm not, I can find myself shouting - inexplicably - at the television, which does nothing of course except scare the cats.

OMG-Its-Domo-kun.jpgI don't know about you, but, I have a really hard time listening to the spin, the misrepresentation and, often, the out-right lies I hear being pushed as legitimate fact by "opposition" guests on news analysis programs. Every now and then a viewpoint will strike me as particularly disingenuous. Such was the case yesterday on MSNBC.

Wendy Wright, President of Concerned Women for America, squared off against GOProud Executive Director Jimmy LaSalvia on Chris Jansing's morning segment to discuss fiscal vs. social conservatism in the new congress. The result was a perfect example of how "facts" become common wisdom - particularly on the right.

Video and much more after the jump.

All three participants are guilty in this, umm... discussion of spreading misinformation, or propagating myths; Chris Jansing sits idly by while Ms. Wright spouts well memorized percentages of people who are against same-sex marriage, against DADT repeal, against abortion etc. Not once does Jansing point out the context of the numbers. If you weren't listening carefully, you may have missed that it was 82% of Tea Party members who were opposed to same-sex marriage. Not only does Jansing not call Ms. Wright out, she effectively allows Wright to control the conversation by failing to interrupt for reaction from Jimmy LaSalvia.

LaSalvia doesn't do much better than Wright, he meekly protests that GOProud is "pro-life" as if he feels compelled to justify being gay and throwing womens' reproductive rights under the bus in the process. The segment ends with the most absurd conflation on Wright's part; denial of domestic partner benefits is fiscally responsible and fiscal responsibility is a moral issue, therefore; it is a moral imperative to deny insurance benefits to unmarried partners, in this case, specifically, same sex partners.

Once my blood-pressure had begun to fall below stroke danger, I thought some more about what I had just witnessed and came to some conclusions:

Wendy Wright and her ilk do not really believe they are morally superior. Only insanity or deep character flaws like greed or lust for power can explain such rationalization of a morally bankrupt position.

Jimmy LaSalvia should be bound and gagged for the duration of the equality movement. His comments point out the need for us, as a community to unify around the concept of equality and stop speaking only for our own little corner of the sky.

Chris Jansing should go back to reading the news, or at least ask for a new producer. Perhaps it seemed (to the person who books her guests) like a good idea to short circuit the broader issues of fairness and equality in favor of a ginned-up split within the republican party. It wasn't.

The most startling realization however, was that a person not accustomed to thinking in terms of equality, may have erroneously concluded the matter closed. Done. Over with. Not so much concluding that Wright was right, but that with the numbers on her side the struggle was all but lost. It isn't.

We must go on. Furthermore, it is imperative that we learn to control the narrative. The only way we can accomplish this is to unite our goals, codify our language and speak the truth.

I wonder where those cats are hiding?

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

Our media has long been divided by the Liberal Vs. Conservative dichotomy. It's Fox Vs. MSNBC and neither have any credibility.

Years a go I began to understand politics as just another sport or game. Two teams going at it (and spinning) but the only thing that really matters is the "score" and that's determined on election day. The "news" isn't educational or even thought provoking any more. It's boring.

I occasionally see Rachel Maddow's program and it's all just "preaching to the choir," nothing is gained.

So, instead of yelling at the TV, go to

I guess I all but abandoned the Broadcast News Media, instead I prefer getting my information online from several sources. Besides I am not getting MSNBC or FOX News anymore.

But at least it is as close to a justified killing of a "TV" as anyone can claim.