E. Winter Tashlin

Showtunes Sing-Off 'Luck Be A Lady'

Filed By E. Winter Tashlin | September 29, 2012 10:00 AM | comments

Filed in: Entertainment
Tags: Adam Arkin, Brando, Dee Snyder, Kate Mullins, Luck Be A Lady, Only Men Aloud!, Peter Gallagher, Showtunes Sing-Off, Sinatra


"Luck Be A Lady" is a song so indelibly associate with legendary crooner Frank Sinatra that it's sometimes hard to remember that in the classic 1955 film version of "Guys and Dolls" it was sung by co-star Marlon Brando rather than Frank.

Brando, who was hardly the gods' gift to song, reportedly struggled mightily with the musical elements of the film, and the version of "Luck Be A Lady" that we hear in the movie is a patchwork of many takes spliced together to make one usable song.

Ten years after the film version of "Guys and Dolls" was released, Sinatra got some of his own back when he recorded the song for his album Sinatra '65: The Singer Today, quickly adopting it as one of his signature pieces.

Today the song endures as a classic. I was first introduced to it as a boy seeing the film of "Guys and Dolls," during which I fancied that in the end Sky would grow bored with his stick in the mud Salvation Army sergeant, and Nathan, having reach the point where he couldn't handle Adelaide's whining for a moment longer (I after all, could barely survive one song), would take his hand and the two wastrels would stroll their way down Broadway, together forever. It's possible that I was a slightly naive child.

Watching Brando's rendition of this song however, it is inconceivable to me how anyone could be surprised that he batted for the boys' team, at least some of the time. I know that there're cultural differences due to the film being nearly a half-century old, not to mention that musicals bring out a bit of the queen in everyone, but there are moments in this film when he really comes off as a bit of a faygeleh.

I don't feel like I can feature "Luck Be A Lady" without at least acknowledging that it's hardly the most forward thinking song in the history of musical theater when it comes to women. There's nothing like an all male chorus defining what it means to be a "lady" after all. Still, underlying misogyny and all, this song remains a standard against which other Broadway songs are measured, and there's no shortage of versions out there.

Here are a small sample, let us know which you prefer in the comments:

Marlon Brando

I'm going to begin with the 1955 film version as sung by Brando, because honestly, if not for the fact that it appeared in one of the most popular musical films of all time, I wouldn't have even included it here.



Frank Sinatra

This was the highest vocal quality version of Sinatra's version. I apologize for it not being a video, but we all know what Frank looked like anyway.



Peter Gallagher (1992 Broadway Revival)



Kate Mullins



Dee Snyder (feat. Clay Aiken)



Only Men Aloud! from BBC's Last Choir Standing



Frank Sinatra & Chrissie Hynde (Duet)



Adam Arkin & The Cast of 'Chicago Hope'

I feel a little guilty posting this one, but they unleashed this on an unsuspecting world, the least I can do is not let them forget it.

(img src)

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.